By Christine Fernando, Related Press
CHICAGO (AP) — Donald Trump has had a tricky time discovering a constant message to questions on abortion and reproductive rights.
The previous president has consistently shifted his stances or supplied obscure, contradictory and at occasions nonsensical solutions to questions on a difficulty that has develop into a serious vulnerability for Republicans on this 12 months’s election. Trump has been making an attempt to win over voters, particularly girls, skeptical about his views, particularly after he nominated three Supreme Courtroom justices who helped overturn the nationwide proper to abortion two years in the past.
The most recent instance got here this week when the Republican presidential nominee stated some abortion legal guidelines are “too robust” and could be “redone.”
“It’s going to be redone,” he stated throughout a Fox Information city corridor that aired Wednesday. “They’re going to, you’re going to, you find yourself with a vote of the folks. They’re too robust, too robust. And people are going to be redone as a result of already there’s a motion in these states.”
Trump didn’t specify if he meant he would take some form of motion if he wins in November, and he didn’t say which states or legal guidelines he was speaking about. He didn’t elaborate on what he meant by “redone.”
He additionally appeared to be contradicting his personal stand when referencing the strict abortion bans handed in Republican-controlled states because the Supreme Courtroom overturned Roe v. Wade. Trump not too long ago stated he would vote in opposition to a constitutional modification on the Florida poll that’s geared toward overturning the state’s six-week abortion ban. That call got here after he had criticized the regulation as too harsh.
Trump has shifted between boasting about nominating the justices who helped strike down federal protections for abortion and making an attempt to look extra impartial. It’s been an try to string the divide between his base of anti-abortion supporters and the vast majority of Individuals who assist abortion rights.
About 6 in 10 Individuals assume their state ought to typically permit an individual to acquire a authorized abortion in the event that they don’t wish to be pregnant for any cause, based on a July ballot from The Related Press-NORC Heart for Public Affairs Analysis. Voters in seven states, together with some conservative ones, have both protected abortion rights or defeated makes an attempt to limit them in statewide votes over the previous two years.
Trump additionally has been repeating the narrative that he returned the query of abortion rights to states, although voters should not have a direct say on that or every other challenge in about half the states. That is significantly true for these residing within the South, the place Republican-controlled legislatures, a lot of which have been gerrymandered to provide the GOP disproportionate energy, have enacted a number of the strictest abortion bans since Roe v. Wade was overturned.
At present, 13 states have banned abortion in any respect phases of being pregnant, whereas 4 extra ban it after six weeks — earlier than many ladies know they’re pregnant.
In the meantime, anti-abortion teams and their Republican allies in state governments are utilizing an array of methods to counter proposed poll initiatives in no less than eight states this 12 months.
Right here’s a breakdown of Trump’s fluctuating stances on reproductive rights.
Flip-flopping on Florida
On Tuesday, Trump claimed some abortion legal guidelines are “too robust” and could be “redone.”
However in August, Trump stated he would vote in opposition to a state poll measure that’s trying to repeal the six-week abortion ban handed by the Republican-controlled Legislature and signed by Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis.
That got here a day after he appeared to point he would vote in favor of the measure. Trump beforehand known as Florida’s six-week ban a “horrible mistake” and too excessive. In an April Time journal interview, Trump repeated that he “thought six weeks is simply too extreme.”
Trump on vetoing a nationwide ban
Trump’s newest flip-flopping has concerned his views on a nationwide abortion ban.
Throughout the Oct. 1 vice presidential debate, Trump posted on his social media platform Fact Social that he would veto a nationwide abortion ban: “Everybody is aware of I might not assist a federal abortion ban, underneath any circumstances, and would, in truth, veto it.”
This got here simply weeks after Trump repeatedly declined to say through the presidential debate with Democrat Kamala Harris whether or not he would veto a nationwide abortion ban if he had been elected.
Trump’s working mate, Ohio Sen. JD Vance, stated in an interview with NBC Information earlier than the presidential debate that Trump would veto a ban. In response to debate moderators prompting him about Vance’s assertion, Trump stated: “I didn’t talk about it with JD, in all equity. And I don’t thoughts if he has a sure view, however I don’t assume he was talking for me.”
‘Professional-choice’ to 15-week ban
Trump’s shifting abortion coverage stances started when the previous actuality TV star and developer began flirting with working for workplace.
He as soon as known as himself “very pro-choice.” However earlier than changing into president, Trump stated he “would certainly assist a ban,” based on his ebook “The America We Deserve,” which was revealed in 2000.
In his first 12 months as president, he stated he was “pro-life with exceptions” but additionally stated “there must be some type of punishment” for girls looking for abortions — a place he shortly reversed.
On the 2018 annual March for Life, Trump voiced assist for a federal ban on abortion on or after 20 weeks of being pregnant.
Extra not too long ago, Trump advised in March that he would possibly assist a nationwide ban on abortions round 15 weeks earlier than saying that he as a substitute would depart the matter to the states.
Views on abortion drugs, prosecuting girls
Within the Time interview, Trump stated it needs to be left as much as the states to determine whether or not to prosecute girls for abortions or to watch girls’s pregnancies.
“The states are going to make that call,” Trump stated. “The states are going to must be comfy or uncomfortable, not me.”
Democrats have seized on the feedback he made in 2016, saying “there must be some type of punishment” for girls who’ve abortions.
Trump additionally declined to remark on entry to the abortion tablet mifepristone, claiming that he has “fairly sturdy views” on the matter. He stated he would make a press release on the difficulty, however it by no means got here.
Trump responded equally when requested about his views on the Comstock Act, a nineteenth century regulation that has been revived by anti-abortion teams looking for to dam the mailing of mifepristone.
IVF and contraception
In Could, Trump stated throughout an interview with a Pittsburgh tv station that he was open to supporting rules on contraception and that his marketing campaign would launch a coverage on the difficulty “very shortly.” He later stated his feedback had been misinterpreted.
Within the KDKA interview, Trump was requested, “Do you assist any restrictions on an individual’s proper to contraception?”
“We’re taking a look at that and I’m going to have a coverage on that very shortly,” Trump responded.
Trump has not since launched a coverage assertion on contraception.
Trump additionally has supplied contradictory statements on in vitro fertilization.
Throughout the Fox Information city corridor, which was taped Tuesday, Trump declared that he’s “the daddy of IVF,” regardless of acknowledging throughout his reply that he wanted an evidence of IVF in February after the Alabama Supreme Courtroom dominated that frozen embryos may be thought of kids underneath state regulation.
Trump stated he instructed Sen. Katie Britt, R-Ala., to “clarify IVF in a short time” to him within the aftermath of the ruling.
As considerations over entry to fertility remedies rose, Trump pledged to advertise IVF by requiring medical health insurance corporations or the federal authorities to pay for it. Such a transfer could be at odds with the actions of a lot of his personal social gathering.
Even because the Republican Social gathering has tried to create a nationwide narrative that it’s receptive to IVF, these messaging efforts have been undercut by GOP state lawmakers, Republican-dominated courts and anti-abortion leaders throughout the social gathering’s ranks, in addition to opposition to legislative makes an attempt to guard IVF entry.
The Related Press receives assist from a number of personal foundations to reinforce its explanatory protection of elections and democracy. See extra about AP’s democracy initiative right here. The AP is solely answerable for all content material.
