There are two kinds of election posters adorning billboards in downtown Tbilisi. The primary, for the ruling Georgian Dream celebration, has the color and stars of the EU flag, vaunting Georgia’s future as an EU member.
The second kind can be for GD, since virtually no websites had been made accessible to opposition events within the centre of the town. Darker and extra menacing, these posters juxtapose scenes of destruction in Ukraine — the collapsed bridge at Irpin, the ruined theatre in Mariupol — with pristine buildings in Georgia. The message is obvious: select GD, a celebration managed by the pro-Russian oligarch Bidzina Ivanishvili, for peace, or again the opposition and convey struggle.
Whereas the pro-EU message of the primary posters is calculated to garner assist in a rustic the place the overwhelming majority of individuals are in favour of becoming a member of, these latter posters have outraged many Georgians, who really feel a deep sense of solidarity with Ukraine. The mountainous Caucasus nation has fought two wars with Russia since gaining independence from the Soviet Union in 1991. Moscow’s seizure of the areas of Abkhazia and South Ossetia in 2008 — with little resistance from the west — marked the start of Vladimir Putin’s try and re-establish a Russian empire by way of navy may.
“It’s so insulting to most Georgians once you attempt to capitalise on the distress of our mates and use it for political ends,” says Tina Bokuchava, chief of the largest opposition celebration, United Nationwide Motion.
“It’s a very uncommon case of the federal government terrifying its personal residents for celebration profit,” says Elene Khoshtaria, chief of Droa! (It’s time), a part of the liberal opposition group, Coalition for Change.
Each Georgians and out of doors observers see the October 26 parliamentary election as a very powerful since independence three a long time in the past: a pivotal second that can decide whether or not the nation turns into a sovereign democracy built-in with the west, or falls again into autocracy and Russia’s orbit.
“All the things that Georgia has been by way of over the previous 30 years — defending its identification, its European values and its European path, and its independence from the outdated colonial energy that’s Russia — all of that’s at stake,” says President Salome Zourabichvili in an interview with the Monetary Instances. She was elected in 2018 with GD’s assist, however has since change into a fierce critic of its authoritarian flip.
Putin and his proxies are preventing exhausting to make sure that Russia’s former Soviet neighbours stay in its sphere of affect, and never simply by way of the invasion of Ukraine. In Moldova earlier this week, President Maia Sandu got here inside a whisker of shedding a referendum on EU membership after a pro-Russian vote-buying operation funded by Ilan Şor, a fugitive oligarch residing in Moscow. Now it’s Georgia’s flip.
“Georgia is rather more essential than the future of 4mn individuals on the opposite facet of the Black Sea,” says Steven Everts, director of the European Union Institute for Safety Research think-tank. “It is usually about what’s Europe, what are European values? It’s a battle for the soul of Europe.”
The election pits GD in opposition to a fractious opposition that has coalesced into 4 events. The UNM is one, whose dominant determine is Mikheil Saakashvili, the jailed former president.
Each authorities and the opposition alliance declare to be on target for victory, making a conflict over the outcome virtually sure. Opposition leaders, civil society representatives and analysts concern Georgia may comply with the instance of Belarus, the place a fraudulent election in 2020 resulted in full-scale repression with Moscow’s backing.
GD insists that avoiding struggle with Russia is one among its principal successes, alongside quick financial progress, which hit 7.5 per cent final 12 months, and rejects the concept Georgia’s place on the earth is at stake.
FT Edit
This text was featured in FT Edit, a every day collection of eight tales to tell, encourage and delight, free to learn for 30 days. Discover FT Edit right here ➼
“The opposition frames this election as a geopolitical alternative, Europe versus Russia,” says Nikoloz Samkharadze, a GD MP. “We [the GD] don’t see it as an election that can outline the destiny of Georgia for the subsequent 500 years. For us, this can be a common election the place issues at stake are the financial system, social welfare, infrastructure and preservation of peace and stability.”
Nonetheless, the posters are only one a part of an aggressive marketing campaign that, critics say, bears the hallmarks of a Russian propaganda and manipulation operation, together with a flood of disinformation on social media.
“It’s fully alien to the Georgian tradition, custom, and mentality of a rustic that has traditionally skilled frequent wars and invasions,” says President Zourabichvili.
Since coming to energy in 2012, GD has put loyalists answerable for main state establishments, together with the judiciary, the electoral fee and the central financial institution. Earlier this 12 months, the federal government defied mass demonstrations to push by way of an NGO “transparency of overseas affect” regulation — much like one enacted in Russia — that critics say can be used to silence dissent.
It has additionally adopted laws curbing LGBT rights and made adjustments to the tax code to exempt property transferred into the nation from offshore jurisdictions. The adjustments probably favour Ivanishvili, whose fortune is estimated by Bloomberg to be $7.5bn in a rustic whose GDP is $30bn.
Most provocative of all, in August the federal government stated it will search to ban the UNM celebration and its “satellites”. To critics, these actions underscore how far the nation has veered in direction of authoritarianism below 12 years of GD rule — and the way a lot additional it may go if returned to energy.
Ivanishvili served briefly as Georgia’s prime minister in 2012 earlier than taking a again seat. He has continued to regulate and bankroll GD, and was made its honorary chair, a task that enables him to decide on the celebration’s candidate for prime minister.
“At all times take heed to a dictator,” says Khatia Dekanoidze, a former minister of schooling and opposition MP. “Dictators say what they need to do.”
In a uncommon TV look on the pro-government broadcaster Imedi this week, Ivanishvili stated that Georgia’s opposition was managed by a “world struggle celebration” — a time period he started utilizing earlier this 12 months to explain the west.
Georgia’s post-independence path
If Georgian democracy is at stake, so is the west’s credibility. After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the EU vowed to reinvigorate its long-stalled technique of enlarging to japanese and south-eastern Europe, arguing there needs to be no extra gray zones that Moscow may exploit.
Ukraine and Moldova had been quickly granted “candidate standing”, step one on the trail to membership, adopted by Georgia late in 2023. However Georgia’s accession course of has abruptly been frozen by the EU due to the federal government’s authoritarian shift.
For the US, Georgia has little financial or strategic significance. However in a troubled post-Soviet area, it has served as a uncommon beacon of democracy and reform. Although the Biden administration has sought to make strengthening democracy a precept of its overseas coverage, that too might be misplaced.
GD’s opponents are satisfied the ruling celebration will win not more than 35 per cent of the vote; GD, in the meantime, has claimed that its assist stands at 60 per cent. There are few dependable printed surveys, however analysts aware of inside polling for each side say the election is finely balanced, with the whole lot depending on turnout. The nation has a completely proportional electoral system, however a 5 per cent threshold for parliamentary illustration poses a problem for smaller events and will ship victory to GD.
President Zourabichvili says the federal government has been strong-arming public servants to again it, roughing up opposition activists, bullying the media, discrediting democracy activists and making it exhausting for the Georgian diaspora to vote. Professional-democracy NGOs are scrambling to ship observers to greater than 3,000 polling stations. But GD’s management of the central election fee and judiciary are fuelling suspicions that it’ll repair the vote.
Georgia has a historical past of democratically elected leaders turning autocratic earlier than they’re faraway from energy. Eduard Shevardnadze was toppled within the Rose Revolution in 2003. Saakachvili’s reformist authorities ended up as a police state and was defeated within the 2012 election when Ivanishvili united the opposition in opposition to him. Now it’s Ivanishvili’s flip.
“This time we’ve seen Georgian Dream actually digging in, clinging to energy by any means, and there’s no assure that if there’s a 50-50 election the place they’ve misplaced the bulk that they’ll play honest,” says Tom de Waal, a Caucasus professional at Carnegie Europe, a overseas coverage think-tank.
GD’s bombastic anti-western rhetoric took a extra drastic flip this 12 months after Ivanishvili returned to the political fore. A reclusive determine with eccentric pursuits — he has stored a pet shark and as soon as imported large baobab bushes from Kenya for his personal arboretum — he’s surrounded by yes-men and shielded from actuality, in accordance with analysts.
Individuals who have recognized the billionaire at totally different levels of his profession say he appears inclined to conspiracy theories. Giga Bokeria, who served as his nationwide safety adviser and is now an opposition politician, recollects Ivanishvili asking a “private query”: was Israel’s overseas intelligence service Mossad liable for the 9/11 terror assaults on the US?
“He’s the loneliest man within the Caucasus,” says Hans Gutbrod, professor of public coverage at Ilia State College in Tbilisi.
Ivanishvili started selling the “world struggle celebration” phrase final April, throughout a speech accusing western powers and their “brokers” of attempting to grab management of his nation. In line with Gutbrod, this isn’t mere rhetoric: “My robust sense is that Bidzina really believes within the ‘world struggle celebration’ and believes individuals are out to get him.”
High of Ivanishvili’s listing has been Washington. In line with Irakli Kobakhidze, his prime minister, Ivanishvili believes that the US is in some way concerned in his long-running dispute with Credit score Suisse, which he claims defrauded him of practically $1bn (a courtroom present in his favour, however the case is on enchantment). This has led to a breakdown in relations with the Biden administration.
But in that Imedi TV interview, Ivanishvili stated he was able to make peace with the US, saying “the explanations [preventing it] have resolved themselves”.
Not like Moldova’s pro-Russian opposition, Ivanishvili will not be overtly doing Putin’s bidding. But Ivanishvili spent his youth within the brutal world of Russian enterprise throughout the Nineteen Nineties, the place he made his fortune from computer systems, banking and heavy trade.
The extent of his ongoing contacts is a matter of dispute. He has offered his Russian companies, however an investigation by Transparency Worldwide Georgia discovered that he owned a minimum of one enterprise in Russia by way of offshore firms.
“There isn’t a proof that he’s had any contact with any political chief or any chief in Russia,” insists Samkharadze, the GD MP, describing accusations as “low-cost propaganda”.
But Victor Kipiani, a lawyer who previously represented Ivanishvili, suggests the state of affairs is extra nuanced. “I’ve by no means seen any proof that anybody in Georgian Dream receives directions [from Moscow],” he says. “Nevertheless, there may be some marriage of comfort that arrives on the coincidence of pursuits with Russia.”
The GD authorities has declined to undertake western financial and monetary sanctions in opposition to Russia and refused entry to Russian opposition politicians. This confirmed a “diploma of co-ordination”, says Carnegie Europe’s De Waal, however Ivanishvili has tried to maintain the Kremlin at arm’s size. “I might describe it as an appeasement coverage in direction of Russia fairly than an alignment coverage,” he provides.
On Moscow’s half, the previous nationwide safety adviser Bokeria says it isn’t as if the Kremlin has to challenge orders to the Georgian authorities.
“They elevated financial dependency on Russia and allowed Russian penetration of the safety and political constructions. That’s all they wanted.”
Georgia’s president, together with the opposition and civil society activists, have got down to body the elections as a referendum on the nation’s future European integration.
Their calculation is that after a clearly pro-EU inhabitants — an estimated 80 per cent of Georgians assist membership — understands that the nation is veering within the unsuitable course, they may vote in opposition to the GD authorities. Opposition events hope to capitalise on the vitality of younger individuals in cities who turned out of their a whole lot of 1000’s to protest in opposition to the NGO regulation.
“Persons are able to struggle for his or her alternative as a result of it’s not a celebration alternative,” says Khoshtaria, co-leader of Coalition for Change. “They perceive they’re shedding their very own future.”
With the election quick approaching, EU officers have issued more and more stark warnings that Georgia’s accession is in danger if voters again a celebration whose actions are incompatible with the bloc’s values. Final week, EU overseas coverage chief Josep Borrell stated Saturday’s vote was a “second of reality”.
Policymakers are baffled that the election nonetheless appears so shut. One purpose, suggests Gutbrod, is that GD voters could not regard EU accession as a precedence: they maybe need to look forward to the bloc to evolve into the extra socially conservative mannequin advocated by Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, an ally of Ivanishvili.
One other is that Georgia’s fractious opposition, for all that it’s briefly united, is tainted by the presence of Saakashvili, a extremely divisive determine revered by fellow reformers however reviled by victims of his anti-corruption purges and more and more repressive regime.
Notably, Saakashvili’s UNM celebration has resisted President Zouribchvili’s push, ought to GD lose, for all 4 opposition teams to again an interim technocratic authorities tasked with getting Georgia’s EU accession again on monitor.
Some Georgians, in the meantime, blame the EU. “Nobody paid correct consideration,” says Tengiz Pkhaladze, a former Georgian official now on the Brussels-based European Centre for Worldwide Political Financial system think-tank.
Whereas Washington has taken punitive actions — imposing sanctions on regulation enforcement officers for his or her repression of anti-government protests and withdrawing an invite for the prime minister to attend a US reception throughout the UN Normal Meeting — the response has hardly been muscular.
“There was a drift into the Kremlin orbit,” says Giorgi Kandelaki, a former opposition MP who’s now director of the Soviet Previous Analysis Laboratory, a human rights group.
A GD rally in central Tblisi on October 23 drew tens of 1000’s of individuals, lots of them state staff. Giorgi, a hierodeacon at Holy Trinity Cathedral, the principle cathedral of the Georgian Orthodox Church, additionally in his 60s, was current. These elections are pivotal, he says. “If the Georgian Dream doesn’t win, I don’t know what’s going to occur to Georgia.”
Vano, 41, the proprietor of a building enterprise who didn’t attend the rally, expresses a unique view. He used to assist GD however has modified his thoughts. “They’ve been in energy too lengthy; it’s time for change,” he says.
Everts of the EUISS argues that the EU and its western companions want to organize clearer and harder responses if the election is certainly adopted by a authorities crackdown. These may embody the specter of private sanctions in opposition to Ivanishvili and his circle, though Hungary is more likely to veto such a transfer.
“We dropped the ball on Georgia,” Everts says. “We’ve been so targeted on different crises that we let GD regularly take management of state establishments. It by no means appeared critical sufficient to focus and intervene. The subsequent few weeks will decide whether or not it slips away or not.”
