A latest commerce proposal was pitched within the PuckPedia GM discussion board that might shake up the Toronto Maple Leafs’ offensive lineup: buying ahead Bryan Rust and depth winger Drew O’Connor from the Pittsburgh Penguins in trade for Nick Robertson, David Kampf, and defensive prospect William Villeneuve. With Toronto’s offense (particularly the workforce’s energy play) sputtering, including a confirmed top-six ahead like Rust would possibly present the spark they want. The Penguins would achieve youthful property to kick-start a retool.
Right here’s a breakdown of the professionals and cons, laying out the case for and in opposition to this potential commerce.
Causes the Commerce Might Work: The Case for Bringing in Bryan Rust and Drew O’Connor
Purpose 1. Rapid Influence on Offense
Bryan Rust is a talented winger with a robust scoring document. He might slot straight into Toronto’s high six, supporting Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner. Rust’s constant manufacturing (56 factors in 62 video games final season) exhibits he can ship underneath strain. He’s skilled enjoying in high-stakes conditions, having received two Stanley Cups with the Penguins. Whereas not at Rust’s stage, Drew O’Connor might add some grit and scoring depth to Toronto’s struggling backside six.
Purpose 2. Rust Has Energy Play Potential
Toronto’s energy play has began the season poorly. It’s ranked far down the NHL’s scale, with a simply over 10% success price. Rust’s skillset might increase the man-advantage unit, including one other dependable shooter and playmaker to a workforce that’s grown overly reliant on Matthews. Rust’s versatility and offensive instincts would possibly assist break the workforce’s energy play hunch and create extra scoring alternatives.
Purpose 3. Recent Begin for Nick Robertson
Promising younger ahead Nick Robertson has struggled to search out constant footing in Toronto. Pittsburgh might provide him the change of surroundings he wants, particularly underneath GM Kyle Dubas, who initially drafted him. For Robertson, transferring to a workforce with much less scrutiny is likely to be the appropriate step in creating his sport with out the high-pressure setting he faces in Toronto.
Towards the Commerce: Causes the Maple Leafs Ought to Hesitate
Purpose 1. Excessive Value for a Win-Now Transfer
Dropping Nick Robertson and David Kampf would deplete the workforce’s depth. Kampf, specifically, has been a reliable bottom-six middle. He gives strong defensive play in an space the place Toronto already faces challenges. Shifting Kampf would doubtless imply relying extra closely on youthful, less-experienced gamers in defensive roles. The commerce might weaken Toronto’s lineup.
Purpose 2. Rust Brings Age and Contract Issues
Bryan Rust is within the third 12 months of a six-year, $30.75 million contract with a $5.125 million annual cap hit. Though Pittsburgh would retain a small portion of Rust’s wage, including a participant in his 30s with a hefty contract would pressure Toronto’s already squeezed wage cap flexibility. Rust’s manufacturing would possibly decline over the remaining contract years, doubtlessly burdening the Maple Leafs if his efficiency dips.
Purpose 3. The Commerce Would Sacrifice the Maple Leafs Defensive Potential
Whereas William Villeneuve continues to be creating within the AHL, he has proven potential to change into a strong NHL defenseman. Given Toronto’s persistent want for defensive depth, buying and selling away Villeneuve dangers dropping a younger, reasonably priced choice who could possibly be NHL-ready within the coming seasons. Sacrificing a future defensive asset might backfire, particularly because the Leafs try and shore up their blue line long-term.
Weighing the Trades’ Execs and Cons
Drawing a metaphorical line down the middle, the professionals of the commerce are evident. Toronto will get an instantaneous offensive increase, with Rust doubtlessly sparking their energy play and O’Connor including depth. This commerce additionally clears the trail for Robertson to develop underneath much less strain in Pittsburgh, the place he would possibly notice his potential with the Penguins.
On the flip aspect, the cons are equally important. Dropping Kampf creates a defensive void that is likely to be exhausting to fill, and including Rust’s contract comes with monetary threat and age considerations. Furthermore, Toronto’s defensive prospect pool is already skinny, making Villeneuve’s departure doubtlessly expensive in the long term.
The Maple Leafs face a basic win-now versus future-building determination. Including Rust might elevate their scoring however on the expense of roster flexibility and defensive depth. If the workforce prioritizes speedy offensive impression and believes Rust can be a difference-maker, the commerce could possibly be well worth the threat. Nevertheless, in the event that they worth long-term asset administration and protection, holding onto their youthful gamers is likely to be the extra clever alternative.
I vote for the latter.
Associated: 3 Takeaways from the Maple Leafs’ 4-1 Kraken Win
