'Cheaper doesn't imply higher': Millennial couple purchased their first dwelling in 2021 for $195,500—now they remorse it

Robert Giametta, 33, and Christopher Luquer, 31, have been dwelling in a two-bedroom residence in Kingston, New York, and paying $850 a month in lease when the covid-19 pandemic struck.

Rates of interest have been low and “I assumed if we do not purchase a home now then we most likely will not have the ability to purchase one sooner or later.” Giametta tells CNBC Make It.

The couple began their search within the Summer season of 2020. They knew they wished to remain inside 40 minutes of Kingston, the place Luquer labored as a income cycle specialist. Giametta, a course of enchancment analyst, labored remotely.

“We wished to discover a home that the mortgage wasn’t going to be sky excessive,” Giametta says. “We wished to renovate.”

Giametta and Luquer have been additionally positive that they wished a three-bedroom home so they may use one as a craft room.

The couple toured 4 homes, put a proposal in on the primary one they noticed — and have been outbid. Finally, they selected a three-bedroom one-and-a-half bed room one-level home in Cairo, New York for $195,500. At a little bit over 1,000 sq. toes, the home additionally has a two-car storage and a again deck and sits on 0.69 acres.

Inbuilt 1970, Giametta says the property was in actually good situation, however in a rural space.

“We have been a little bit bit nervous at how rural it was, however we satisfied ourselves that it will be enjoyable,” he says. “[The home] was solely barely outdated, so after we noticed it, we thought it will be very easy to replace and would not value that a lot cash.”

“It was the proper starter dwelling and was a little bit bit higher than the opposite ones that we noticed for the worth,” he added.

The 2 closed on the home in January 2021 with a down fee of about $6,000. They secured a month-to-month mortgage of $1,300 with a complete FHA mortgage of $192,000.

Giametta and Luquer moved in that very same month. “I could not imagine that we owned a home. I am a millennial, so it isn’t one thing that appeared achievable for us, nevertheless it occurred,” Giametta says. “It was actually surreal, and it felt actually good to know we had overcome this big hurdle of our era.”

“It was emotional as a result of we lived in flats and had horrible experiences with neighbors and landlords, so it was good that we did not have anybody over us,” he provides.

The couple spent the primary 12 months renovating and even purchased a hen coop, which Luquer had at all times dreamed of getting. Giametta estimates the renovations value between $20,000 to $30,000: “We have been very distracted and centered on the home to start with.”

However by the summer season of 2022, the couple began regretting their buy.

The home’s rural location in began to weigh on them. Luquer’s state of affairs at work modified and he grew to become absolutely distant. And their mates stopped making the trouble to hang around with them now that they have been additional away. “We began to really feel like we’re on their own up right here,” Giametta says.

This October, Giametta shared his home-buying remorse on TikTok, and the clip racked up over 55,000 views.

“There’s probably not something to do round right here and it is changing into actually miserable,” he says within the video. “I am discovering out that I’m rather more of a metropolis individual fairly than a rustic individual since being right here.”

One other factor that bugs the pair is Cairo’s older inhabitants — there aren’t many individuals their age in any respect.

“I do not suppose we might have purchased this home if we have been each distant on the time,” he says within the TikTok. “We might have been on the lookout for an even bigger metropolis like Boston or New York Metropolis and even Seattle.”

The low value of dwelling outdoors of a significant metropolis was a significant factor of their choice, however now Giametta says that “simply because it is cheaper doesn’t suggest it is higher.”

“I might say that not contemplating location is the largest remorse,” he provides.

The couple has determined they don’t seem to be going to remain in the home upstate and are weighing their choices.

They have been interested by itemizing their dwelling on Airbnb or renting it out, however discovered from neighbors that the property had a historical past of getting used that approach and had been left in dangerous situation.

Giametta and Luquer say the last word aim is to complete renovations after which attempt to promote the home in two years.

“It isn’t going to be nice however I feel if we do not take it gradual on the subsequent step, we’ll find yourself with one other remorse,” Giametta says. “I feel we type of have simply to chew the bullet and chill out with the decrease mortgage price we’ve now and embrace being a hermit.”

Giametta has shared a number of extra movies in regards to the couple’s expertise and says the primary query he received was why they did not take into consideration the placement extra earlier than shopping for the home.

“You actually do not know till you are there. You possibly can understand what it will be like as a lot as you need however you are not going to know till you really do it and see the way it feels,” he says.

Although they remorse shopping for this dwelling, the couple do have one constructive takeaway.

“That is our first home, and we discovered rather a lot that we are able to use afterward,” Giametta says. “I assume it is only a studying expertise in life.”

Need to make extra cash outdoors of your day job? Join CNBC’s on-line course Tips on how to Earn Passive Revenue On-line to study widespread passive revenue streams, tricks to get began and real-life success tales.

Plus, join CNBC Make It is e-newsletter to get suggestions and tips for achievement at work, with cash and in life.