Giants’ Daniel Jones regarded like a damaged QB, however benching him now can be an overreaction

Is the New York Giants’ season already on the brink after one recreation? That’s the way it feels after a disheartening 28-6 loss to the Vikings in Sunday’s season opener.

Right here’s a remaining have a look at one more discouraging season opener:

Jones’ final stand?

Giants quarterback Daniel Jones made the primary begin of the second season since signing a four-year, $160 million contract on Sunday. He has solely made seven begins since signing that deal and has solely completed 5 video games.

But, coach Brian Daboll fielded questions postgame Sunday and once more throughout his Monday postmortem about whether or not he’ll bench Jones. Daboll affirmed that he’s sticking with Jones.

It might appear wild that Daboll is fielding these questions so early within the season. But it surely’s wilder that the questions are utterly respectable.

It’s not simply that Jones didn’t carry out nicely in Sunday’s loss. It’s that he regarded like a rattled, damaged quarterback. He regarded even worse than he did final season when critical considerations about his future had been raised by poor efficiency and accidents.

Benching Jones after one ugly exhibiting in his return from a torn ACL can be an overreaction. But it surely’s honest to marvel in regards to the size of his leash.

Daboll had a fast hook for underperforming veterans in his first two seasons. Broad receiver Kenny Golladay was benched after one recreation in 2022, and guard Mark Glowinski acquired the identical therapy final season.

However altering quarterbacks is a much more consequential resolution, particularly with no assurances that backup Drew Lock might be a major improve. It could be a lot completely different if Giants normal supervisor Joe Schoen had efficiently traded up for a quarterback on this 12 months’s draft. The calls to play the rookie can be deafening already. Suppose again to Jones’ rookie season in 2019 when he took over because the starter after franchise icon Eli Manning was benched in Week 3.

Even and not using a quarterback of the longer term ready within the wings, Daboll’s endurance will develop skinny if Jones doesn’t flip issues round shortly. A good matchup in opposition to a foul Commanders protection that allowed 37 factors in a Week 1 loss to the Buccaneers might sign Jones’ final stand.

If Jones flops in opposition to the Commanders, a quarterback change ought to change into a critical consideration subsequent week.

Not a priority

It’s apparent that Jones’ harm assure — the Giants will owe him $23 million if he suffers an harm and may’t go a bodily if the workforce cuts him subsequent offseason — isn’t weighing on Daboll’s thoughts.

Daboll referred to as three energy runs for Jones, exposing the quarterback to extra hits in his first recreation again from a significant harm. Jones wants to make use of his legs to be an efficient quarterback, so Daboll can’t name performs with a concern of harm.

Trailing 28-6, Daboll referred to as timeouts to get the ball again throughout Minnesota’s remaining possession. The Vikings punted to the Giants with 1:36 remaining, and Daboll stored Jones within the recreation.

The one rationalization for protecting the quarterback and the remainder of the starters in for a garbage-time drive is that Daboll was making an attempt to offer the offense an opportunity to finish the sport with some optimistic emotions. As an alternative, Jones took two extra hits on a pathetic drive that resulted in a punt again to the Vikings with 29 seconds remaining.

Outmatched

Brian Flores was a finalist for the Giants’ head teaching job that went to Daboll in 2022. Flores infamously didn’t get that job — and he nonetheless has a pending discrimination lawsuit in opposition to the Giants, Broncos, Texans and the NFL — so the Vikings defensive coordinator had further motivation to make a press release on Sunday.

Flores definitely acquired the higher of Daboll within the battle of former Invoice Belichick assistants.

Daboll’s recreation plan was primarily based on an expectation of a pressure-heavy assault from the ultra-aggressive Flores. However Flores threw a curveball, blitzing on simply 22.4 % of the snaps on Sunday, in response to Subsequent Gen Stats. Flores led the league with a 48.8 % blitz charge final season.

The Giants leaned on heavy personnel with two and three tight ends in an try to attenuate the unique appears to be like Flores might deploy on early downs. That was comprehensible in concept, however it didn’t play to the Giants’ strengths, that are at broad receiver. They don’t have dynamic receiving weapons at tight finish, so getting the Vikings to place larger defensive personnel on the sphere didn’t yield mismatches within the passing recreation.

ICYMI: Meet up with @DDuggan21 and I’s dwell room from yesterday. AKA a really good remedy session for #giants followers. https://t.co/S4Ku1u0ucM

— Charlotte Carroll (@charlottecrrll) September 10, 2024

The Vikings electing to not ship further rushers in opposition to the Giants’ large personnel led to a number of max defend go performs with seven or eight defenders in protection. That helps clarify the shortage of a deep passing assault as a result of the Vikings had loads of defensive backs to cowl two receivers operating routes.

Conceivably, the larger personnel can be a lift for the run recreation, however the Giants couldn’t get something occurring the bottom. Devin Singletary, Eric Grey and Tyrone Tracy mixed for 45 yards on 14 carries (3.2 yards per carry).

The shortcoming to run the ball or go successfully on early downs compelled the Giants right into a whopping 18 third downs. The Giants went 6-for-11 on third-and-7 and shorter and 1-for-7 on third-and-8 and longer. Clearly, stepping into so many third-and-longs is just not a recipe for achievement, particularly as a result of that allowed Flores to deploy the kind of appears to be like Daboll was aiming to keep away from.

Getting conservative

Daboll seems to have misplaced his nerve as an aggressive coach. After conservatively calling a pair of Jones keepers, Daboll was confronted with fourth-and-3 from the Vikings’ 49-yard line with 4 minutes left within the second quarter. Trailing 14-3, Daboll elected to punt. The insecurity within the offense was palpable on the 2 Jones runs and the choice to punt.

Trailing 28-6 late within the third quarter, the Giants had fourth-and-3 on their very own 37-yard line. Daboll stored the offense on the sphere, however it was simply so Jones might attempt to attract the Vikings offside with a tough rely. That didn’t work, so the Giants took a delay of recreation penalty and punted. It most likely wouldn’t have mattered if the Giants transformed in that spot, however Daboll waved the white flag with the punt.

Unusual decisions

There have been some head-scratching personnel selections within the opener. Cor’Dale Flott, who labored solely at outdoors nook in the course of the offseason, was the beginning slot nook within the Giants’ nickel bundle. Rookie Dru Phillips, who had gained the beginning slot nook job in camp, was relegated to a diminished function within the dime bundle.

“Simply on the brink of go right here for the primary recreation, we thought that that was one of the best factor for us,” Daboll mentioned.

Phillips made an influence in restricted motion, forcing a fumble on his first profession snap. Phillips took over because the slot cornerback within the second half after nook Nick McCloud left with a knee harm, and Flott shifted outdoors.

Daboll indicated Flott will most likely play outdoors extra going ahead, particularly with McCloud “day-to-day, possibly week-to-week.”

Linebacker Micah McFadden didn’t play regardless of not being listed as questionable on the harm report. McFadden had been coping with a groin harm that restricted him in observe final week. Daboll mentioned McFadden was on a pitch rely, however wasn’t used as a result of rookie Darius Muasau performed nicely. Muasau tallied six tackles and an interception whereas taking part in 82 % of the snaps in his debut.

Returner Gunner Olszewski aggravated his groin harm in pregame warmups and might be out “weeks,” in response to Daboll. Whereas a pregame re-injury was not possible to foretell, the Giants paid for not having a real backup punt returner lively contemplating Olszewski clearly wasn’t one hundred pc.

The Giants solely had 51 gamers on the lively roster for the opener in a cost-cutting transfer. That made it indefensible to not have a backup punt returner on the roster. Broad receiver Darius Slayton, who had no punt returns in his first 5 seasons, was compelled to interchange Olszewski. That was an journey, as Slayton didn’t subject his first punt cleanly after which fumbled the return.

The Giants signed Ihmir Smith-Marsette to interchange Olszewski after figuring out returners on Monday. A fifth-round decide by the Vikings in 2021, Smith-Marsette has been on 4 groups in three seasons. He averaged 8.7 yards on 37 punt returns for the Panthers final season. He was launched by Carolina on Aug. 28.

Second-year broad receiver Jalin Hyatt performed simply 23 % of the snaps, and even that whole is deceptive. Hyatt performed simply three snaps within the first half earlier than getting most of his taking part in time when the sport was determined within the fourth quarter.

The Giants gave Hyatt each alternative to win the No. 2 receiver job in camp, however Slayton proved to be a greater, extra dependable choice. Hyatt had a foul drop on his lone goal on Sunday.

Daboll referred to as Hyatt the workforce’s “third/fourth” receiver, so it looks like he has floor to make up. However he might get a possibility this week as a result of Slayton is within the concussion protocol.

Out for the 12 months?

Carter Coughlin is probably going out for the season after Daboll mentioned the linebacker might be out for “months” with a pec harm. Coughlin was on the lively roster earlier than getting reduce final Thursday and re-signed to the observe squad Friday. He was then elevated Sunday, taking part in 10 snaps on particular groups earlier than the harm.

The Giants juggled the roster for monetary causes, as Coughlin’s $1.1 million wage would have been assured for the season if he was on the lively roster for Week 1 as a result of he’s a vested veteran. Making him a observe squad elevation offered the workforce extra flexibility with Coughlin, though his harm will reduce into the financial savings from the roster gymnastics. Coughlin will make $570,000 for the season, which is the minimal wage for a participant together with his expertise on IR.

Formation notations

The Giants principally performed a base 3-4 protection and a nickel bundle with two defensive linemen, 4 linebackers and 5 defensive backs on Sunday. Defensive coordinator Shane Bowen used a dime bundle eight instances on passing downs.

Deonte Banks and Adoree’ Jackson had been the perimeter cornerbacks with Phillips or Flott within the slot within the dime bundle. Dane Belton was the third security within the bundle, taking part in within the field on the “cash” place. With Belton filling that function, Isaiah Simmons didn’t play a defensive snap.

The Giants added outdoors linebacker Azeez Ojulari to Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux on three third downs within the dime bundle within the second half. Burns lined up off the ball throughout from a guard on these three snaps. Like the remainder of the sport, the bundle with the three outdoors linebackers didn’t produce a lot of a go rush.

(Picture of Daniel Jones: Mitchell Leff / Getty Photographs)