Unlock the Editor’s Digest free of charge
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.
Once I first moved to Mumbai three years in the past supply app Dunzo turned a necessary lifeline within the semi-locked down megacity on the tail-end of the coronavirus pandemic.
Even earlier than Covid, the pioneering digital courier service, which connected prospects with the nation’s legion of small family-owned shops and grocers, had developed a fan following in its residence base of Bengaluru, sparing residents outings within the infamous site visitors of India’s expertise hub.
Since then ultra-speedy deliveries inside 20 minutes have turn out to be ubiquitous within the nation’s congested metros. On-line disrupters unexpectedly shuttling small quantity orders additionally caught favour amongst households with low disposable incomes and restricted storage in cramped properties.
The intensive cash-burning operations have overcome preliminary trade scepticism after establishing deep networks of darkish shops that home a wide-range of products — from fizzy drinks to recent greens — in a compact supply radius.
Whereas remaining a sliver of India’s general retail market, the nation’s digital fast commerce sector has witnessed a greater than 10-fold annual growth over the previous couple of years to turn out to be a $3bn market in 2023, in response to JM Monetary.
The Indian funding financial institution estimated earlier this yr that the trade measurement may attain $40bn by the top of the last decade, as tens of millions of urbanite Indians turn out to be addicted “to a hypnotic dose of worth and comfort”.
“The rise of fast commerce has taken an entire lot of individuals, together with me, by huge shock,” says Arvind Singhal, chair of India retail-focused consultancy Technopak Advisors. “Now to me something greater than 20 minutes seems to be very sluggish — it’s unimaginable.”
However extra just lately it has turn out to be tough for me to get deliveries with Dunzo and several other of my orders have been cancelled. It seems to have come underneath monetary strain regardless of deep-pocketed buyers together with Google and Reliance Retail, an arm of Mukesh Ambani’s conglomerate.
Indian media have reported that the start-up laid off 75 per cent of its core employees final month, with simply 50 remaining, and that any additional capital increase would possible sharply scale back the $744mn valuation it acquired final yr.
Whereas Dunzo’s founder Kabeer Biswas didn’t reply to a request for remark, analysts say the app did not persuade customers to shift to its in-house Dunzo Each day service, its darkish community of shops.
Many shoppers have been possible postpone as its supply charges climbed in a rustic the place each rupee is counted by thrifty households, Singhal says. Akshay D’Souza, a shopper guide, provides: “They acquired pushed in the direction of a extra worthwhile mannequin a little bit too quickly.”
Dunzo’s demise is one a part of a wider trade consolidation.
Lots of India’s as soon as 10 energetic gamers have folded and fast commerce is now dominated by a trio of trendsetting apps — Blinkit, owned by listed takeaway firm Zomato; Softbank-backed Swiggy and Zepto. The latter just lately raised funds at a $5bn valuation, indicating there’s nonetheless investor urge for food to again the winners of the consolidation.
Whereas the market leaders stay unprofitable, they’re steadily rising revenues as they give the impression of being to develop additional exterior India’s three largest cities — Bengaluru, Delhi and Mumbai.
Redseer Technique Consultants expects at the very least 500 new darkish shops shall be added this yr with a concentrate on the highest 30 to 50 city centres.
Their maintain shall be more and more challenged by highly effective native and overseas giants, which have been initially caught off guard. India’s Tata Sons, in addition to world ecommerce titans Amazon and Walmart, are closely investing and launching their very own fast companies.
Sustaining requirements whereas increasing exterior of India’s most prosperous cities shall be essential. A survey of 24,000 individuals by Indian pollster LocalCircles late final yr discovered many shoppers have been shifting away from shopping for recent produce on-line.
The standard of fruit and greens supplied by the platforms was low, in response to 73 per cent of the respondents, who stated they have been heading again to their native markets after dealing with points with poor stock inventory and because the apps diminished reductions.
Buyer loyalty shall be additional examined if supply charges are raised to spice up profitability. “It’s a money burn enterprise,” says D’Souza, who expects that direct prices to the patron must go up. “Ultimately there shall be strain on lots of these fast commerce platforms to drive profitability.”
chris.kay@ft.com