Brian Daboll’s bungling of Graham Gano’s damage emblematic of mismanaged Giants throughout his tenure

LANDOVER, Md. — The catastrophe was so predictable that any seasoned New York Giants observer may see it occurring in actual time.

Washington’s Austin Ekeler broke by means of a crowd and darted into the open area on Sunday’s opening kickoff of the Giants’ 21-18 loss. The lengthy return compelled Giants kicker Graham Gano to offer chase, which resulted in catastrophe.

Gano pulled his hamstring as Ekeler blew previous him into the tip zone. The landing was referred to as again attributable to a holding penalty, however Gano was left writhing in ache on the sphere.

Shedding the kicker on the primary play of the sport would have merely joined the listing of dangerous breaks to plague the Giants throughout their interminable run of incompetence if there wasn’t a way that it may have been averted. However Gano had been added to the damage report Saturday with a groin damage, and he skilled sufficient discomfort throughout pregame warmups that he disrupted his typical routine to retreat to the locker room to get his groin wrapped.

So the Giants had loads of discover to deploy a contingency plan for his or her hobbled 37-year-old kicker. The obvious resolution was elevating kicker Jude McAtamney from the follow squad on Saturday to have a ready-made insurance coverage coverage.

GO DEEPER

NFL Week 2 takeaways: What Chiefs’ newest survival exhibits, Ravens issues, Saints thriving

However even when the Giants elected to not elevate McAtamney, they nonetheless may have added a safeguard after Gano’s disjointed warmup routine. Punter Jamie Gillan may have stuffed in on kickoffs to protect Gano for area targets and additional factors, thus eliminating any probability of chasing any returners for 40 yards.

As a result of it’s the Giants, these choices got here again to hang-out them within the worst method conceivable. Gillan, who had made 1-of-2 area purpose makes an attempt in his six-year profession, missed the additional level following the Giants’ first landing, so coach Brian Daboll elected to aim 2-point conversions after the staff’s last two scores. Daboll additionally eschewed a 40-yard area purpose on fourth-and-4 with simply over two minutes remaining in a tie recreation.

Each 2-point makes an attempt failed, and rookie large receiver Malik Nabers’ lone lowlight from a monster 10-catch, 127-yard, one-touchdown efficiency got here with a drop on the fourth down. The Commanders drove down after Nabers’ drop and kicked the game-winning area purpose. In a merciless poetic twist, Austin Seibert, whom Washington signed Tuesday, went 7-for-7 on area targets Sunday.

So in a recreation determined by three factors, the Giants failed on three extra-point makes an attempt due to Gano’s damage, they usually bypassed a possible go-ahead area purpose as a result of Daboll didn’t belief Gillan.

“We thought Graham could be OK,” Daboll mentioned. “He acquired damage chasing down a (runner). It was a hamstring. He didn’t damage his groin.”

These are the kinds of catastrophes that result in a coach getting requested about his future two video games into his third season. Daboll was requested if he’s involved about his job safety if the outcomes don’t change.

“I’ve finished this for a very long time. My focus is on our soccer staff,” Daboll mentioned earlier than directing an prolonged glare on the reporter who requested the query.

Brian Daboll is requested if he is involved about his job standing:

“My focus in on our soccer staff” pic.twitter.com/YmxGs7YGqU

— Giants Movies (@SNYGiants) September 15, 2024

That was Daboll’s lone testy second in his information convention that he opened by praising his staff’s competitiveness, the play of quarterback Daniel Jones and enhancements made after a 28-6 loss to the Vikings in Week 1. Daboll clearly had calmed down after slamming his headset to the bottom as Seibert’s 30-yard game-winning area purpose break up the uprights as time expired.

It’s outstanding how rapidly issues have turned for Daboll. He was named coach of the yr 18 months in the past after his surprisingly profitable debut season. However the Giants are 6-13 because the begin of final season and 9-18-1 because the midpoint of Daboll’s first season.

No matter contact he had throughout his first season has disappeared. As a substitute, there have been too many missteps, with personnel blunders just like the Gano mismanagement changing into an alarming development.

Extremely, the Giants have put themselves on this scenario earlier than with Gano. The kicker was coping with a left knee damage early final season, however he continued to kick till he missed two area targets in a 13-10 additional time loss to the Jets in Week 8. Gano was shut down after that recreation and underwent season-ending knee surgical procedure.

There was an analogous snafu final week with returner Gunner Olszewski, who suffered a groin damage in follow earlier than the second preseason recreation. Olszewski was restricted in follow main into Week 1 however was deemed able to play. He then reinjured his groin in pregame warmups and can miss no less than 4 weeks after being positioned on injured reserve on Saturday.

The Giants didn’t have an skilled returner available regardless of Olszewski coping with the groin damage for 3 weeks, so large receiver Darius Slayton was pressed into punt return responsibility. Slayton did not cleanly area his first return after which fumbled the ball, however it was recovered by a teammate.

What’s so troubling about these errors is that they’re nearly fully within the arms of Daboll and common supervisor Joe Schoen. They’re not the identical as permitting the Commanders, led by rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels, to transform 50 p.c of their third downs or to hurry for 215 yards. These are disappointing outcomes, however there’s a wide range of components concerned.

However setting the sport day lineup is one thing each fantasy soccer proprietor can handle. And it wasn’t an advanced puzzle to assemble to have McAtamney lively, both.

The Giants used their two follow squad elevations on linebackers Ty Summers and Tomon Fox. That duo didn’t play a defensive snap however was on the sphere for each kickoff, kickoff return and punt return. May the Giants have used different gamers already on the lively roster for these 13 performs? Positive, however even that wasn’t essential.

The Giants had solely 52 gamers on their 53-man roster after putting Olszewski on IR on Saturday. So they may have signed Summers to the 53-man roster and used an elevation on McAtamney, an undrafted rookie signed out of Rutgers.

The Giants then would have wanted to make yet one more participant inactive. They probably would have survived with out their No. 5 defensive deal with Jordon Riley taking part in a handful of snaps, particularly on the expense of not having a backup plan for Gano.

“All the selections which are made are mine,” Daboll mentioned, earlier than later including that roster choices are a collective course of with Schoen.

“I can not let you know that he will get damage chasing a 100-yard kickoff return that was referred to as again”

Brian Daboll with extra on the Graham Gano scenario: pic.twitter.com/7ZEqqkueJz

— Giants Movies (@SNYGiants) September 15, 2024

Some of these miscues are emblematic of an total sloppy operation. The advantage of the doubt from this regime’s surprising 12 months 1 success has pale. Now Daboll wants to determine the right way to pull the staff out of this spiral.

The primary two video games of the season have been speculated to be the straightforward a part of the schedule. Regardless of how bleak issues have gotten for the Giants throughout this wretched decade-long stretch, they’d no less than been capable of rely on beating Washington. With even that off the desk, it’s onerous to see the place wins will come from.