On Jan. 11, Texas quarterback Quinn Ewers posted a video to greater than 200,000 followers on Instagram. In it, he signed a buying and selling card together with his face and added a message under.
“I’m coming again,” he wrote, holding the cardboard as much as the digicam.
The highest touch upon the publish?
“Yall gonna lose manning (sic),” it learn, including a pair of laughing emojis aimed on the Longhorns’ predicted misfortunes.
Manning, as in Arch Manning: five-star recruit, and the son of Cooper, nephew of Eli and Peyton and grandson of Archie. Ewers’ shocking choice was about chasing Texas’ first nationwide title since 2005, however the commenter wasn’t alone in directing consideration to varsity soccer’s most well-known backup in an period wherein there isn’t any penalty for transferring.
Even earlier than Ewers elected to return, Manning confronted questions on the Sugar Bowl about whether or not he needed to go away after barely seeing the sphere in his first season.
“It’s robust since you wish to be on the market enjoying along with your boys,” Manning advised The Athletic in July. “However simply realizing there’s nowhere else I wish to be, and it was my dream to play at Texas. I’m going to stay it out and play there finally,”
GO DEEPER
Arch Manning and different QBs clarify choice to switch or keep put
He made the identical choice as Ewers: He was coming again. He was at all times coming again. Now, Manning is more likely to make his first profession begin towards Louisiana-Monroe on Saturday, as Texas coach Steve Sarkisian stated Ewers is questionable to play after straining his indirect towards UTSA.
“Arch is simply one other man on our crew, and the rationale I’m ready to try this is as a result of that’s who Arch is day-after-day,” Sarkisian stated Monday. “He’s the selfless teammate. He cares concerning the guys on the crew. He cares about Quinn. They’ve acquired an excellent relationship. He works his tail off. He needs to play good soccer for them as a result of he is aware of how laborious all people’s working.
“So I actually don’t handle it with him. I don’t handle it with the crew. He’s simply a part of the crew.”
Arch Manning threw for 223 yards and had 5 whole TDs versus UTSA. (Tim Warner / Getty Pictures)
There was a time when quarterbacks seeing the sphere earlier than their second or third 12 months was an anomaly. Now, it’s an expectation, at the least for five-star prospects. When Manning’s identify by no means appeared within the switch portal, he bucked a decade of developments amongst school quarterbacks.
Switch portal choices are distinctive to each participant, however as Manning enters what is predicted to be his first begin, we’re seeing the the explanation why leaving would introduce extra questions than solutions and current extra issues than options.
Although Manning has thrown solely 23 passes in 4 appearances since arriving in 2023, issues have largely gone in keeping with plan at Texas — even when successful the beginning job was delayed by a 12 months due to Ewers’ return. Manning continues to be one good season away from crystallizing his standing as a first-round draft decide, and he has loads of time to do it, with three years of eligibility remaining after this season. His path to the sphere grew to become clearer when final 12 months’s backup, Maalik Murphy, transferred to Duke, and one other 12 months working behind Ewers was solely going to make the outcomes higher as soon as it was time for his flip within the highlight.
His rising pains have largely been in a position to are available in closed practices. They haven’t needed to are available in nationally televised video games like younger quarterbacks who’re requested to be saviors like freshmen Dylan Raiola at Nebraska and DJ Lagway at Florida. However when he has been given the chance, he’s excelled. On Saturday, thrust into prolonged obligation towards an overmatched UTSA crew, he threw a landing cross on his first try, scooted previous a security for a 67-yard landing run and completed with three extra landing passes in a 56-7 blowout win.
GO DEEPER
With Quinn Ewers injured, Arch Manning tallies 5 TDs vs. UTSA
Now, if he begins Saturday, he’ll do it for a Texas crew ranked No. 1 within the AP ballot for the primary time since 2008, when Colt McCoy was beneath middle for the Longhorns. McCoy, by the way in which, didn’t play his first season at Texas both.
Since highschool, the whole lot the Mannings have achieved with Arch factors to a big-picture strategy, aiming for a prolonged NFL profession, not the quickest path to the enjoying area or one of the simplest ways to earn cash from his fame in school. Manning’s recruitment was straight out of 1995: In case you don’t have DMs, reporters and coaches can’t slide into them, and it’s simpler for coaches and fogeys to manage coaches’ entry to you, too.
He’s a non-factor on social media. He barely spoke to reporters about his school choice, a household technique borne out of a need to permit him to reside a extra regular highschool life. His household background affords him the power to shrug off the obligations of chasing NIL cash, as does his standing as a possible NFL Draft decide after he does get on the sphere.
GO DEEPER
Arch Manning’s distinctive strategy to recruiting
Now, his choice to remain affected person in school is old-school, too. NIL cash is the invisible hand guiding gamers into and out of the switch portal, however the success that his household has loved means cash was by no means going to affect his choice. As of final December, his solely NIL deal was an unique buying and selling card partnership with Panini America, regardless of faulty reviews that he was incomes hundreds of thousands as Texas’ third-string quarterback. After initially declining to be included, he elected to decide into his identify, picture and likeness being utilized in EA Sports activities’ Faculty Soccer 25.
Manning has achieved little to nothing to “develop his model” and but the model he was born with has made him one of many 5 greatest names in school soccer.
Ewers returned to Texas with nationwide title aspirations in Texas’ first season within the SEC after reaching the Faculty Soccer Playoff a season in the past and narrowly dropping to Washington within the semifinals. His religion in Sarkisian and the crew returning to Austin has to this point been rewarded, and Manning noticed the identical factor.
If this system had been on shakier floor coming into the SEC, it stands to motive Manning might need entertained coming into the portal. However Texas is as sturdy because it’s been for the reason that heyday of Mack Brown within the 2000s. Why would Manning depart and alter to new coaches, a brand new play caller, a brand new offense and a brand new head coach for what would virtually definitely be a worse crew?
And there’s the uncomfortable actuality that Ewers, who may very well be the primary quarterback taken within the 2025 NFL Draft, has been one of many extra injury-prone QBs in school soccer, whilst he’s developed into among the best. When he strained his indirect Saturday, he did it because the betting favourite for the Heisman Trophy. In 2022, he missed a shade beneath 4 video games after injuring his shoulder in an in depth loss to Alabama. In 2023, he missed two Huge 12 video games with a sprained AC joint in his shoulder. Texas turned to Murphy to maintain its Huge 12 and nationwide title hopes on monitor and survived an upset bid from Kansas State whereas Ewers healed.
Now, Ewers is injured once more, and Manning seemed like America’s finest backup quarterback in reduction towards UTSA.
No matter Ewers’ readiness to play, handing Manning the keys for a recreation towards ULM wherein Texas is favored by 45 factors is the prudent choice. The following two opponents, Louisiana-Monroe and Mississippi State, are unlikely to check the Longhorns, and Ewers appears more likely to return by the point the nationwide championship pressures enhance when Texas’ date with Oklahoma within the Pink River Showdown arrives on Oct. 12 earlier than Georgia involves city on Oct. 19.
When Ewers stayed for another surprising 12 months in Austin, it was simple to count on Manning to behave like each different quarterback and develop a drifting eye to discover a new program. However Manning leaving Texas by no means made sense. His school soccer expertise isn’t like each different quarterback’s.
Why wouldn’t his decision-making be completely different?
(High illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; images: Eric Homosexual / Related Press; Tim Warner / Getty Pictures)
