You’d assume that spirits can be excessive amongst school soccer followers throughout the nation. A brand new season is beginning, and the expanded 12-team Faculty Soccer Playoff affords extra postseason alternatives than ever earlier than.
However there’s really a little bit extra pessimism at this level than in the previous couple of seasons, in response to our annual Hope-O-Meter survey.
No fan base is totally hopeless — like at Stanford final 12 months — however supporters of 15 of the 70 power-conference faculties (and sure, we’re nonetheless together with Oregon State and Washington State) mentioned they’re extra pessimistic than optimistic heading into the 2024 season. That’s a rise of six faculties from this time final 12 months and 4 greater than in 2022.
GO DEEPER
Faculty soccer bowl projections: Preseason picks from CFP to Bahamas Bowl
Convention realignment and the lack of gamers to the switch portal are the first causes followers at many colleges are groaning. In the identical breath, there are extra applications flush with hope than in recent times — at seven Energy 4 faculties, 100% of respondents are hopeful getting into the season, and at six others, all however one fan is optimistic.
Followers at Appalachian State, Boise State and Memphis are additionally 100% hopeful, realizing their applications have a shot to earn the one assured Group of 5 spot within the 12-team discipline.
It needs to be famous, in fact, that our survey was performed earlier than Florida State misplaced to Georgia Tech.
Essential matters
So, what have been essentially the most generally used phrases or phrases followers typed to explain what they’re feeling, and which fan bases used them essentially the most?
• “Switch portal” got here up near 300 occasions among the many 4,000-plus responses and was used most by joyous Florida State, NC State, Notre Dame, Ohio State and Syracuse followers.
Followers of Group of 5 faculties weren’t almost as happy with the portal.
“NIL and switch portal don’t favor the Group of 5 faculties,” Colorado State fan Joe Anderson writes. “They’re now minor league developmental applications for the P4 faculties.”
GO DEEPER
Our consultants’ Faculty Soccer Playoff, Heisman and nationwide title predictions
• “Recruiting” got here up 147 occasions and was used most by Auburn, Missouri, Nebraska and USC followers — some joyful, some not.
“Hugh Freeze’s recruiting abilities give us hope for the longer term,” Auburn fan David writes.
“Recruiting has by no means been hotter at Mizzou,” Missouri fan Mike writes.
Trojans followers have been a little bit extra down on Lincoln Riley’s efforts.
“Recruiting within the entrance seven and offensive line has been a catastrophe the previous couple cycles, and I’m afraid that can present itself this 12 months,” Patrick O writes. “USC will be unable to compete nationally till it will get this mounted by the following couple of cycles.”
• After arising 42 occasions in surveys final 12 months, “realignment” was talked about solely 11 occasions this 12 months — largely from upset followers of former Pac-12 faculties in addition to these preventing to stay related in a strengthened SEC and Huge Ten.
One fan who cheers for each Oregon State and Purdue writes: “Unmitigated avarice destroyed a sport I’ve at all times cherished and decimated a plucky, lovable program that was on the rise. My different workforce, Purdue, doesn’t stand to fare a lot better and can little question be misplaced within the subsequent spherical of greed-motivated realignment.”
GO DEEPER
Ten school soccer gamers (apart from the QBs) who might determine the Playoff race
A South Carolina fan is anticipating the worst due to a harder schedule.
“Whereas I like Shane Beamer and assume he’s performed a strong job, this workforce may very well be higher this 12 months and nonetheless wrestle to get to 5-7,” Jesse W. writes. “The realignment of the SEC with the addition of Texas and Oklahoma has made what was already a herculean job much more tough.”
A few followers from Arizona and Stanford mentioned they’re performed watching school soccer.
We’ll see.
The place confidence is brimming
So, which fan bases are strolling round fully happy with the path of their favourite workforce?
Let’s begin with Oklahoma State, the place Mike Gundy is getting into his twentieth season total and his first with out Oklahoma and Texas on the schedule.
Ben Humpkin is pumped: “Nearly everybody comes again from a 10-win workforce. What’s to not like? Plus, the Land Robbers are off the schedule.”
NC State hasn’t received double-digit video games in a season since Chuck Amato and Philip Rivers teamed as much as win 11 video games and the Gator Bowl in 2002. Most Wolfpack followers are feeling cautiously optimistic, however some like Hayden are flexing with Grayson McCall at quarterback.
“It’s going to be bizarre seeing an offensive-oriented Dave Doeren workforce, however that is far and away essentially the most proficient offense I’ve seen in my life as an NC State fan. The receiver room is loaded with expertise and Grayson McCall is a confirmed veteran presence that doesn’t make many errors. Tony Gibson at all times produces an amazing protection so if all of it comes collectively, be careful.”
As you may count on, Ole Miss followers are additionally stuffed with hope after Lane Kiffin cleaned up within the portal. Clifton Van Cleave expects nothing lower than making the Playoff discipline.
“I believe we can have one of the best workforce for the reason that 1960’s — Playoff-bound for positive.”
Confidence is one thing new for Kansas followers.
Will writes: “Kansas has a reliable shot to win the Huge 12 and make the Playoff this 12 months. Returning QB, superior talent place gamers, tons of continuity and returners from a very good workforce a 12 months in the past.”
Largest risers
Indiana followers are fired up. The Hoosiers made the most important soar — up 78 share factors — following the hiring of Curt Cignetti, who went 52-9 in 5 seasons at James Madison.
“Coach Cig has a swagger and confidence this program hasn’t had for a very long time,” Hoosiers fan Joe writes. “The switch portal was aggressively utilized. IU has a comparatively simple schedule. We’re going bowling this 12 months! I predict a 7-5 document going into the bowl sport. Go Hoosiers!”
California is about to journey greater than 24,000 miles on journeys backwards and forwards throughout the nation as a brand new member of the ACC. That hasn’t stopped optimism from growing by 71 share factors as Justin Wilcox heads into his eighth season in Berkeley with a 36-43 total document. John Kaiser says switching leagues is simply what the Bears wanted.
“No. 1 RB within the nation. Everyone seems to be about to learn the way good the Pac-12 was and the way unhealthy the ACC is. First-year convention champions, Playoff berth and the primary Rose Bowl in 100 years. Roll on you Bears.”
West Virginia followers have been buried in pessimism this time final 12 months when the Mountaineers have been picked to complete final within the Huge 12. Then Neal Brown’s workforce went 9-4, and followers are thrilled he’s signed by the 2026 season.
GO DEEPER
The Athletic 134: Rating each workforce from No. 1 Ohio State to No. 134 Kennesaw State
Sam is dreaming large.
“I believe we are able to beat Penn State, and I believe if we do, it can catapult us right into a TCU-esque run the place we needs to be within the thick of the competitors for the Huge 12 title into mid-November. Not saying we’re going to run all of it the best way to the title sport, however I believe we are able to undoubtedly put ourselves in a spot to be within the Playoff dialog.”
Optimism isn’t essentially beaming at Northwestern or Stanford, however hope is manner up from a 12 months in the past — 51 share factors for the Wildcats and 42 for the Cardinal.
Northwestern fan Geoff Newton writes: “The document will doubtless decline, however this system total is in a lot better form than this level final 12 months.”
Different fan bases feeling considerably extra optimistic in comparison with final 12 months: Iowa State (up 41 factors), Syracuse (37), Rutgers (37), Virginia (36), Boston Faculty (35), Virginia Tech (35), Missouri (28) and Michigan State (26).
Largest fallers
On the flip facet, confidence amongst followers has been shaken essentially the most at Pittsburgh (down 65 share factors), Mississippi State (57), Arkansas (55), Purdue (47), Illinois (45), Vanderbilt (42), South Carolina (41), Baylor (40), BYU (40), North Carolina (39), Oregon State (36), Duke (35) and USC (35).
Optimism can be down at three faculties that lately performed within the four-team Playoff.
Nick Butcher was not impressed with final 12 months’s 3-9 season at Cincinnati following Luke Fickell’s departure for Wisconsin.
“My lack of religion comes purely from the pinnacle coach. I actually consider that Scott Satterfield is the worst coach within the Energy 4. I perceive 12 months one within the switch portal period is hard; nevertheless final 12 months’s workforce was not simply unhealthy, they have been undisciplined. That each one comes again to teaching.”
TCU fan Jeffrey Chatman has fully misplaced religion in Sonny Dykes simply two seasons after he led TCU to the nationwide title sport.
GO DEEPER
What’s new within the 2024 school soccer season? 12 issues to know earlier than kickoff
“The Fiesta Bowl playoff sport the place we beat Michigan was one of the best soccer sport of my life. The nationwide championship sport in opposition to Georgia was the worst soccer sport of my life. We adopted that up by going 5-7 and Kendal Briles of the hated Baylor Briles household is the offensive coordinator for my workforce now. … I would like him to win, however I’m not satisfied that Sonny is something greater than a nepo-baby that’s giving his buddies and their children teaching jobs.”
Washington has but to play a sport underneath new coach Jedd Fisch and followers like Katie Carroll are already bracing for the worst.
“It’s not that I believe our workforce doesn’t have expertise, on the sector or on the teaching employees. Sometimes, after reaching a nationwide championship, you’d assume there can be extra pleasure across the program, even with so many gamers and coaches leaving. I believe generally, although, the fan base is simply ready for the opposite shoe to drop: Fisch ditching us for Florida when (Billy) Napier will get fired and beginning this cycle of transfers and decommitments that we actually can’t afford to undergo once more.”
Different highlights from the Hope-O-Meter
(Feedback calmly edited for size and readability.)
• Victor S., hopeful Alabama fan: “Superior expertise. Confirmed employees (simply not in T-City but). Unimaginable power. One thing to show … in my view, The Commonplace is getting a lift!”
• Matt, hopeful Appalachian State fan: “We should always win the Solar Belt and have a practical shot on the Playoff.”
• Daryl, hopeful Arizona fan: “(Receiver Tetairoa McMillan) and (quarterback) Noah (Fifita). That’s sufficient for me.”
• Russ C., pessimistic Arizona State fan: “Herm (Edwards) and Antonio Pierce devastated this system in so some ways it can take a very long time to repair. Plus, altering conferences makes it much less enjoyable.”
• William, pessimistic Arkansas fan: “I simply don’t assume Sam Pittman has it, and bringing again (Bobby) Petrino was a mistake.”
• JD, hopeful Auburn fan: “We’ve already been within the dumps, so why keep there? Received to hope for higher and a minimum of recruiting has improved. Now that Darth Vader left T-town, possibly we are able to get extra magic in The Plains.”
• JTB, pessimistic Baylor fan: “Poor teaching, meager NIL funding. Deliver again Artwork!”
• Kevin W., hopeful Boise State fan: “I believe Boise State has performed nearly the whole lot proper this offseason. From hiring Spencer Danielson as head coach to the recruiting class (each transfers and highschool), and only in the near past saying an settlement to maintain Jeramiah Dickey because the athletic director. It’s been a grand slam. The sky’s the restrict for this workforce. It feels just like the Broncos of outdated are again!”
• Brendan Kelis, hopeful Boston Faculty fan: “Invoice O’Brien is aware of what he’s doing.”
• Adam Swindlehurst, pessimistic BYU fan: “Regardless of the Huge 12 being large open, I haven’t learn a lot that’s constructive about BYU’s probabilities of ending close to the highest of the standings. I’m way more wanting ahead to what our basketball squad goes to seem like.”
• Eric B., hopeful Clemson fan: “In Dabo we belief!!! Tyler from Spartanburg is an fool!”
• Brian, pessimistic Colorado fan: “All flash and no substance but.”
• John H., hopeful Colorado fan: “Six phrases: Coach Prime. Shedeur Sanders. Travis Hunter.”
• Brian, pessimistic Duke fan: “Duke is coming down from two of one of the best coaches at school historical past, and their quarterback transferred. Having a brand new, unproven coach at a particular non-football faculty offers me warning. I can simply foresee some rising pains and a few shut losses.”
• Steve, pessimistic Florida fan: “Billy ain’t it. Rigid. Boring highschool offense. Can’t and won’t make changes. Horrible in-game decision-making.”
• Jim, hopeful Florida fan: “If they may have tightened the screws only a quarter-turn final 12 months, it will’ve been 7-5. Positively count on enchancment this season, although unsure how that displays within the document with our schedule. Offense needs to be good, protection stays a query mark. However I’m hopeful.”
• Lauren R., hopeful Florida State fan: “I belief Mike Norvell.”
• Jeremiah Murphy, hopeful Georgia fan: “Natty or bust.”
• Kurt Hoyt, hopeful Georgia Tech fan: “I consider that Brent Key discovered the fitting classes from Nick Saban and is placing within the work needed to show this system round.”
• Shoe Mama Hensley, pessimistic Houston fan: “We have now an issue. Get it?”
• Greg, hopeful Houston fan: “Willie Fritz means the adults are again in command of this system.”
• Roger C., pessimistic Illinois fan: “In 1982, my freshman 12 months at Illinois, we went to the Rose Bowl, and I assumed we lastly had a very good workforce that might compete for championships. It’s been largely painful ever since. I want I understood why it’s not a very good soccer program. However a minimum of there may be basketball.”
• Drew D., hopeful Iowa fan: “NO BRIAN FERENTZ!!! WOO!!!!”
• Aaron, hopeful Iowa State fan: “OU and Texas are gone. The Huge 12 is ours.”
• Kyle, hopeful Kansas State fan: “Avery Johnson + Dylan Edwards.”
• TJ Pettrey, hopeful Kentucky fan: “Presumably finest protection of (Mike) Stoops period. Former five-star quarterback. Eight wins is a superb season contemplating our schedule.”
• Andrew R., a pessimistic Kent State fan: “May be the worst workforce in all of faculty soccer — no matter division.”
• Michael Benson, hopeful Louisville fan: “Nice coach. Good switch class together with an enormous improve at QB. Above common protection.”
• Norman Anseman, hopeful LSU fan: “I’m on the Nuss Bus. (Garrett Nussmeier) is essentially the most underrated QB in school soccer. If the protection is barely 50 p.c higher than final 12 months, then the remainder of the SEC needs to be scared.”
• Chris, pessimistic Maryland fan: “Maryland simply appears to eternally be caught as a mid-level program.”
• Peter, hopeful Miami fan: “I’ve been damage many, many occasions earlier than by my optimism. But it surely feels totally different this 12 months. I believe the Hurricanes have a good schedule and the expertise to do one thing particular. Now let’s simply hope the teaching employees doesn’t price us.”
• Chris C., hopeful Michigan fan: “It could actually’t be pretty much as good, but it surely may very well be higher than loads assume. And who cares after final 12 months?”
• Jerry S., pessimistic Michigan State fan: “No purpose for optimism at this level. Perhaps in one other 12 months or two.”
• Paul G., hopeful Michigan State fan: “Mel Tucker’s gone, which provides me on the spot hope. Additionally, (Jonathan) Smith appears to be doing all the fitting issues, together with doing decently within the switch portal and with recruiting.”
GO DEEPER
Scandal ‘tore aside’ Michigan State. A brand new coach leads the lengthy climb again
• Jorj, pessimistic Minnesota fan: “Nothing ever modifications. Huge speak. Identical outcomes. Only one extra go online the dumpster hearth that’s Minnesota sports activities fandom.”
• Jackson Burkett, hopeful Missouri fan: “It’s time for individuals, Missouri followers included, to shift their perspective about how good Mizzou may be. Final 12 months we obtained a style of the apple, and now we would like the entire bushel. MIZ-Without end.”
• Ben Jackson, hopeful Nebraska fan: “Dylan Raiola is my lord and savior. Hallowed be thy title.”
• Adam R., pessimistic Nevada fan: “2010 Colin Kaepernick ain’t strolling by that entrance door.”
• Ben A., pessimistic Notre Dame fan: “Appears like expectations are too excessive.”
• John MacCauley, hopeful Notre Dame fan: “Natty or bust.”
• Ron, hopeful Ohio State fan: “The perfect workforce cash can purchase.”
• Ryan, pessimistic Ohio State fan: “Ohio State seems to be nice on paper however hasn’t earned something on the sector but to justify its reward. Like John Cooper, Ryan Day is mentally incapable of beating Michigan.”
• Raffi, hopeful Ohio State fan: “Natty is assured.”
• Luke McConnell, hopeful Oklahoma fan: “Everyone seems to be sleeping on OU going into the SEC. The logic simply doesn’t add up within the rationale for the shortage of optimism from the surface. I believe OU goes to shock individuals, and I believe OU having the ability to have a reliable purpose to play the disrespect card goes to be fairly cool to see and expertise.”
• Todd, hopeful Oregon fan: “Loaded workforce, new convention, challenges are actual. However we’re ready.”
• Jake, hopeful Oregon State fan: “I’ve obtained a chip on my shoulder, and I’m hoping that my squad does too.”
• Fred W., pessimistic Penn State fan: “I’ll consider it once I see it.”
• Kyle H., pessimistic Penn State fan: “I assume I’m optimistic that we are able to go 9-3 and be the thirteenth ranked workforce within the Playoff rankings. In spite of everything, Groundhog Day is a Pennsylvania factor.”
• Mike Davey, hopeful Penn State fan: “Two phrases: Expanded Playoff. Now or by no means for us. We’re!”
• Mike, pessimistic Pitt fan: “Clear regression final season and unsure if (Pat) Narduzzi is aware of what changes to make. The offense was abysmal final 12 months, and whereas a contemporary, youthful offensive coordinator might instill enhancements, I worry that the 2021 ACC title season was extra of a Kenny Pickett, Jordan Addison lightning-in-a-bottle-year, somewhat than the beginning of a sustained interval of eight-, nine-, 10-win seasons.”
• Colin Meyer, hopeful Purdue fan: “Purdue will beat Notre Dame on Sept 14th.”
• Sean, hopeful Rutgers fan: “Finest workforce since 2012.”
• John, hopeful SMU fan: “Ponies have performed effectively within the switch portal. QB Preston Stone is wholesome. Protection seems to be strong.”
• Sue Glickman, hopeful Stanford fan: “However our library! Oh, the books!!”
• Dominic Chiappone, hopeful Syracuse fan: “After almost a decade of being caught in purgatory, that is essentially the most hype I’ve ever seen the Syracuse fan base in my little time as a devoted fan. There may be real pleasure about coach Fran Brown and this system, and that extends past 2024. #InMcCordWeTrust”
• W. Irons, hopeful Tennessee fan: “Heupel-Disciple”
• Kyle G., hopeful Texas fan: “Sark has been harvesting beef. (Quinn) Ewers is battle examined and other people have stopped making ‘Texas is again’ jokes in The Athletic feedback.”
• Rip Collins, hopeful Texas A&M fan: “No Jimbo!”
• E.C. Tex, pessimistic Texas Tech fan: “There must be a 3rd choice: I’m a Texas Tech fan, they’ve the items to win a minimum of eight video games and Joey (McGuire) has performed a very good job to this point, however we heard that final 12 months when Tech fell in need of lofty preseason predictions.”
• Conor, hopeful UCF fan: “Gus Bus! KJ Jefferson and one of the best recruiting this faculty has ever seen!”
• Chris H., pessimistic UCLA fan: “Joyful about Chip (Kelly) being gone, and never a lot else.”
• Justin, hopeful USF fan: “Byrum Brown is likely one of the finest quarterbacks within the G5 and he leads an explosive offense. A robust recruiting haul ought to assist the protection enhance from terrible to only fairly unhealthy. All of it ought to add as much as a second straight bowl sport.”
• James Buckley, hopeful Utah fan: “Playoff-bound if we’re wholesome!”
• Alex Kucera, pessimistic Vanderbilt fan: “We stink out loud.”
• UVA Erik, pessimistic Virginia fan: “We’re doomed.”
• TL, hopeful Virginia Tech fan: “Belief the Pry-cess!!”
• Brett, pessimistic Wake Forest fan: “The present mannequin of faculty soccer is designed to sprint the hopes of small faculties. Faculty soccer isn’t enjoyable anymore except you’re a large state faculty or Notre Dame.”
• Nate S., pessimistic Washington State fan: “As a Coug fan, it’s fairly apparent, we simply grew to become irrelevant on account of a dysfunctional system.”
• Isaac, pessimistic Wisconsin fan: “The glory days are previous.”
Daring predictions
And now to some scorching preseason takes from our employees:
• Scott Dochterman: For the primary time at school historical past, Iowa State will win 10 video games whereas additionally claiming its first league championship since 1912.
• Mitch Mild: The defending nationwide champions will lose a minimum of 5 regular-season video games.
• Chris Kamrani: Shedeur Sanders will win the Heisman Trophy.
• Jayna Bardahl: One of many prime 4 seeds can be upset in its first Playoff sport. Will probably be the second consecutive 12 months with no SEC workforce within the championship sport.
• Pete Sampson: This can be Lincoln Riley’s ultimate season as USC’s head coach.
• Justin Williams: FSU and Clemson keep within the ACC.
• Audrey Snyder: West Virginia finishes within the prime 15.
• Kate Hairopoulos: Colorado makes a bowl sport and Deion returns for 12 months 3. Clemson’s offense is revived and ranks within the prime 15 within the FBS.
• Austin Meek: Kansas and Kansas State will each make the CFP.
• Grace Raynor: When Clemson makes its manner again to the Faculty Soccer Playoff, “Faculty GameDay” will invite Tyler from Spartanburg to be the visitor picker.
• Sam Khan Jr.: Matt Rhule and Dylan Raiola will lead Nebraska to 10 wins this season.
• Joe Rexrode: South Florida’s Byrum Brown can be in New York for the Heisman ceremony and never simply as a spectator.
• Matt Brown: NC State will win its first ACC title since 1979.
• David Ubben: The SEC has three of the ultimate 4 groups left standing. Consequently, there may be some short-sighted purchaser’s regret to the 12-team Playoff.
• Stewart Mandel: The SEC will get 5 groups within the Playoff.
(Prime illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; photographs of Nate Yarnell, Jaxson Dart: James Black, Todd Kirkland / Getty)