Within the following potential commerce situation, the Toronto Maple Leafs wish to bolster their roster throughout their Stanley Cup window by buying two-time Stanley Cup champion Blake Coleman from the Calgary Flames. Nonetheless, they’d have to surrender Nick Robertson and Timothy Liljegren to herald Coleman. Does that commerce make any sense for the Maple Leafs?
The commerce proposal, created utilizing PuckPedia’s PuckGM instrument, is structured as follows:
Within the Flames & Maple Leafs Commerce, Who’s Getting What?
Within the commerce, the Maple Leafs obtain Blake Coleman, who’s a veteran ahead with two Stanley Cup championships. Coleman would deliver expertise and depth to the Maple Leafs lineup. Toronto would additionally choose up the Flames’ 2026 Third-Spherical Choose (from Vancouver. A 3rd-rounder may turn into a useful asset that might contribute to the staff’s future.
Going the opposite means could be Timothy Liljegren, a younger defenseman and 2017 first-round choose who remains to be discovering his footing within the NHL. As nicely, the Flames would get the participant who “may” be one of the best participant within the commerce in Nick Robertson. Though the jury remains to be out on Robertson, he may turn into a robust ahead. Robertson is on an enormous team-friendly extension that he not too long ago signed after requesting a commerce. The Flames would additionally choose up the next draft selection within the 2027 second-rounder. That choose would add one other asset to the Flames stockpile that might help Calgary’s rebuilding efforts.
Critiquing the Deal: Why Commerce Robertson Would Be Questionable
Whereas buying Coleman is sensible for the Maple Leafs as they give the impression of being so as to add a seasoned participant with a confirmed playoff observe document, buying and selling Robertson raises vital questions. Right here’s why transferring Robertson at this juncture may very well be unwise.
First, Robertson has the potential to turn into an NHL expertise. True, he has not but begun to showcase his expertise. Nonetheless, this preseason he has proven flashes of his potential offensive capabilities and spectacular defensive play. His latest performances haven’t solely caught the attention of the teaching employees however have additionally begun to solidify his function within the lineup. At simply 22 years outdated, Robertson’s growth trajectory seems to pattern upwards, suggesting he may turn into a key contributor for the Maple Leafs transferring ahead.
Robertson Has Impressed the Maple Leafs Teaching Workers
Robertson has not too long ago elicited reward from the teaching employees for his efficiency on the ice. On condition that he has been given an opportunity to shine not too long ago, the group is likely to be beginning to see the potential many followers and analysts have lengthy believed he possesses. Shifting a participant simply starting to seek out his groove may backfire, particularly if he continues to develop and enhance in his function.
By buying and selling Robertson, the Maple Leafs threat giving up a participant who may turn into an actual NHL star. Given their present rebuilding part, the Flames would possible welcome the chance so as to add Robertson to their roster. That’s very true given their rebuilding part. If Robertson realizes his potential, he may turn into a major participant for Calgary, making this commerce notably painful for Toronto.
Robertson’s latest success may additionally imply his commerce worth is at an all-time excessive. Nonetheless, buying and selling a participant with such potential leaves the Maple Leafs weak. The group could be sacrificing a promising younger expertise who may simply be starting to scratch the floor of his skills.
The Backside Line: Would Be Dangerous Commerce for Maple Leafs
Whereas Coleman would deliver useful expertise to the Maple Leafs’ playoff run, buying and selling Robertson comes with appreciable threat. His creating expertise and potential star energy recommend he may very well be a key future asset for the staff. The Maple Leafs should rigorously weigh the fast advantages in opposition to the potential of shedding a future standout participant.
Therefore, the commerce shouldn’t happen.
Associated: Marner, Matthews & Ice Time: Maple Leafs Stats After Two Video games
