Politics
/
October 16, 2024
Why is the media speaking a lot in regards to the fraction of Black males who may go MAGA when greater than 60 % of white males will vote for Trump?
Vice President Kamala Harris unveiled a platform of insurance policies to courtroom Black male voters this week, which she referred to as the “Alternative Agenda for Black Males.” The platform contains enterprise loans for Black entrepreneurs, legalization of marijuana, and higher regulation of the cryptocurrency market, which disproportionately predates on Black males.
I’ve learn her plan, as a result of studying such issues is a part of my job, however talking as only a common Black male voter, I actually and deeply don’t give a shit. We’re 4 weeks out from a presidential election in opposition to a deranged fascist named Donald Trump. I don’t want nor require a personalised agenda addressing my specific points at this late date—and if I did want one this might not be it, not the least as a result of it doesn’t comprise any significant option to stop the cops from harassing or murdering me and my Black kids as we attempt to reside out our lives on this racist nation. The time for a Black male agenda was three years in the past when Democrats briefly managed the White Home and each chambers of Congress. As a result of I perceive primary civics, I’ll proceed to handle my inquiries to Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema about why such an agenda by no means materialized.
However I’m not right here to speak in regards to the previous. I don’t want extra dependable crypto and an NFT in my lunchbox telling me I’m a giant robust man as a way to select accurately between a reasonable Black girl and the plain white supremacist who believes in eugenics. I might be voting for Harris on November 5, after which spend the 1,500 days between that date and the following presidential election in 2028 advocating for my model of a Black agenda. Happening TikTok to advocate for Black folks in October means nothing should you don’t present up with the identical power and concepts in January.
It is perhaps tempting to jot down me off as a bougie negro who has misplaced contact together with his neighborhood, however I’d prefer to level out that the overwhelming majority of Black male voters are going to do precisely what I do: vote for Harris. Harris will obtain between 85 and 90 % of the Black male vote. I acknowledge that the distinction between 85 % and 90 % may very well be the distinction in Harris successful or dropping a vital state or two, however I merely refuse to interact in a dialog that paints Black male assist because the “downside” for Harris on this election. Over 60 % of white males are going to vote for a convicted felon. Someplace round 50 % of white girls are going to vote for an adjudicated rapist and religious misogynist. Black males aren’t your downside, Democrats.
The “downside” on this nation is how the bulk of white folks vote. The drive holding this nation again is almost all of white folks. The individuals who have turned in opposition to democracy are nearly all of white folks. The worldwide drive destroying the surroundings of this earth is almost all of white folks. If you’re within the white liberal minority and also you wish to freak out about one thing, freak out about your cousins and grandmothers and colleagues who’re about to forged a poll for an unhinged authoritarian. Go cope with the white folks in your life as an alternative of inserting the burden on Black of us to avoid wasting this nation from nearly all of white of us but once more.
After all, asking white of us to look within the mirror and deal with their very own bullshit has been the plea of each Black thinker and mental from Frederick Douglass to Chris Rock. This nation has grow to be comfy with the concept that white assist for white supremacy is inevitable. The white voters who will assist this fascism are constantly handled by the media as if they’re merely doing the perfect they will given the financial and social forces they consider exist, despite the fact that most of what these white voters consider is factually, demonstrably mistaken.
Present Problem
This fallacious concept that white individuals are at all times doing their greatest—and that it’s as much as everybody else to cease them in the event that they disagree—is such a standard characteristic of American political discourse that you simply’ll nonetheless see a majority of white of us defend the enslavers and rapists who wrote the Structure. They’ll name these founders “males of their occasions,” despite the fact that there have been different, higher males (and girls!) who knew in actual time that slavery was mistaken and girls ought to have political equality. The enslaved folks, as an example, had been “males of their occasions” and knew slavery was mistaken. However most whites, even the “progressive” ones on the time, went together with the unforgivable evil of human bondage. The one time progressive white of us truly stood as much as their racist brothers and cousins was within the 1860s, and the racist whites had been so pissed in regards to the regular operation of democratic governance that elected Abraham Lincoln that they seceded from the Union and began a civil battle. Normally, as an alternative of coping with retrograde white of us, liberal whites search for anyone else accountable.
On this election, the powers that be have determined that Black males are the suitable scapegoat. Sure, the overwhelming majority of Black male voters will vote for Harris, however what about those that don’t vote? What in regards to the dudes who will keep on the sofa? Absolutely, if each Black man would simply crawl over damaged glass to vote for Harris, our democracy may very well be saved. Since not each single sentient brother will carry out their assigned civic responsibility of saving white of us just like the magic negroes we’re speculated to be, clearly Harris should have an issue with Black males—or so the story goes.
Harris doesn’t have a “downside” with Black males. That mentioned, she does seem, primarily based on the polls, to be barely underperforming Joe Biden in 2020 with… males. All males. White males, Black males, Latino males, AAPI males, males with no school diploma, males with a school diploma, working males, enterprise males, and just about each different taste of males, besides maybe Black queer males who seem like all in for the VP.
Gosh, I can’t think about why. Is the truth that America is the one main democracy to by no means have elected a girl as its chief one thing greater than mere coincidence? May or not it’s that too many cis-hetero American males are pathetic little rump creatures who’ve been taught by their fathers and flicks to view girls as prizes to be gained as an alternative of equals to be revered? I suppose there are some issues we’ll by no means know for certain.
To the extent Harris has an issue with males, there’s actually nothing she will do about it. Harris may give Woman MacBeth’s “unsex me right here” soliloquy as a stump speech whereas sporting a pretend beard just like the Egyptian Pharaoh Hatshepsut, and it wouldn’t make a rattling’s little bit of distinction to the misogyny crowd. She’s working in opposition to a person who actually tells different males that it’s okay to seize girls by the genitals. The blokes who need that to be true are by no means going to vote for a girl. There’s not an agenda accessible that may persuade these sorts of males to not suck. To place that in a language these guys can perceive: you’ll be able to’t motive with these males, you simply must kick their ass.
The identical goes for her alleged downside with Black males. There’s nothing she alone can do about it. A coverage agenda that focuses on the precise hurdles that this nation has erected earlier than Black males can’t be addressed by fiat by the President of the USA. It takes laws, handed by Congress. It takes courts prepared to uphold the Voting Rights Act and implement the equal safety of legal guidelines promised by the Structure. It takes governors, state legislatures, and mayors prepared to carry racist police forces accountable for his or her crimes and harassment. It takes politicians dedicated to advancing the problems essential to Black males not for just a few weeks each 4 years, however daily, relentlessly.
Standard
“swipe left beneath to view extra authors”Swipe →
We do want a Black male “alternative agenda,” not as a marketing campaign soundbyte, however as an ongoing dedication to provide as a lot of a crap about Black males on November 6 as folks will faux to by November 4. Greater than any particular coverage, I consider that with Kamala Harris, we now have at the very least the potential for that dedication, and that’s my high ask in an election.
On the very least, I’m constructive that Harris’s dedication to advancing the alternatives for Black males extends past Trump’s dedication to having Black males who’re already profitable shuck and jive for him at his rallies. The Democrats are removed from excellent, however Trump and his Republicans are an anathema that provide tokenism as an alternative of progress. As Dr. Christina Greer expertly defined in a latest piece, Black males are implausible at voting for hurt discount. We all know that the Democratic get together isn’t going to essentially give attention to us, however we additionally know that the Republican get together is going to give attention to us—on hurting us, searching us, crushing us and, given the slightest provocation and alternative, taking pictures us.
Black males aren’t magic, however we’re protectors. Identical to generations of Black girls, we’ll put our our bodies on the road to defend our households, our communities, and our humanity. Most of us will, at the very least—and round 85 to 90 % of us will show it once more within the upcoming election. I hope that is sufficient to counteract the affect of all the boys who aren’t like us.
Can we depend on you?
Within the coming election, the destiny of our democracy and elementary civil rights are on the poll. The conservative architects of Challenge 2025 are scheming to institutionalize Donald Trump’s authoritarian imaginative and prescient throughout all ranges of presidency if he ought to win.
We’ve already seen occasions that fill us with each dread and cautious optimism—all through all of it, The Nation has been a bulwark in opposition to misinformation and an advocate for daring, principled views. Our devoted writers have sat down with Kamala Harris and Bernie Sanders for interviews, unpacked the shallow right-wing populist appeals of J.D. Vance, and debated the pathway for a Democratic victory in November.
Tales like these and the one you simply learn are important at this vital juncture in our nation’s historical past. Now greater than ever, we’d like clear-eyed and deeply reported impartial journalism to make sense of the headlines and type truth from fiction. Donate right this moment and be part of our 160-year legacy of talking reality to energy and uplifting the voices of grassroots advocates.
All through 2024 and what’s possible the defining election of our lifetimes, we’d like your assist to proceed publishing the insightful journalism you depend on.
Thanks,
The Editors of The Nation
Extra from The Nation
At a city corridor occasion in Oaks, Pennsylvania, Donald Trump appeared to surrender on politics and spent 39 minutes nodding alongside to his favourite songs.
Chris Lehmann
Harris has been just about silent on trans rights, and her insurance policies would disproportionately profit well-off trans folks.
Charlie Markbreiter
The previous president’s threats could appear outlandish. However his agenda is genuinely harmful.
Chris Lehmann
James Goodwin, the coverage director on the Middle for Progressive Reform, explains what the “bleak” world of labor beneath Challenge 2025 would appear like.
Q&A
/
Laura Flanders and Maximillian Alvarez