Article content material
An “extremely wasted” John Christopher Arrizza was incapable of forming the intent to homicide deadly stabbing sufferer Ethan Enns-Goneau, his lawyer argued Thursday.
Defence counsel Katherin Beyak mentioned jurors ought to acquit Arrizza of homicide, as an alternative discovering that his lethal assault on the Banff native amounted to manslaughter.
However Crown prosecutor Patrick Bigg mentioned Arrizza’s actions in stabbing his sufferer no less than 11 occasions, 4 of which might have been lethal, confirmed he was able to intending the results of his motion.
Commercial 2
Article content material
In her closing submissions earlier than a Calgary Court docket of King’s Bench jury, Beyak performed video clips from each the Dancing Sasquatch bar, the place Arrizza attacked Enns-Goneau in a basement washroom, and in-car footage following his arrest by an RCMP officer.
In surveillance footage from the bar, Arrizza will be seen bouncing off partitions and twice falling whereas stumbling up a staircase within the minutes main as much as the lethal encounter.
“There may be nothing to counsel that Mr. Arrizza is doing something apart from wandering round extremely wasted,” Beyak mentioned.
The lawyer mentioned even footage wherein Arrizza will be seen stabbing Enns-Goneau a number of occasions after pushing him into the hallway exterior the washroom, reveals her consumer didn’t intend his sufferer to die.
“The incident stops as a result of Mr. Arrizza stops. He’s not hauled off by the bouncers,” Beyak mentioned.
“If, in reality, he wished Mr. Enns-Goneau to die, or if he wished to make sure he inflicted severe accidents on him he might have saved going.”
Arrizza, 24, is charged with second-degree homicide in reference to the Aug. 5, 2022, dying of Enns-Goneau, 26.
Article content material
Commercial 3
Article content material
Enns-Goneau and a good friend had determined to go to the Dancing Sasquatch for a nightcap after a night of ingesting and the sufferer went straight to the washroom upon arrival.
Simply over a minute later he was pushed out of the toilet and completed off by Arrizza.
Beyak mentioned feedback a slurring Arrizza made within the police automotive instantly after his arrest prompt her consumer was reacting to one thing Enns-Goneau did or mentioned.
“He signifies he had been attacked,” Beyak mentioned.
“He was scared, he successfully tried to brandish the knife … and Mr. Enns-Goneau proceeded to struggle him anyway,” she mentioned.
“One thing occurred in that washroom that prompted a response from Mr. Arrizza.”
However Bigg painted a distinct image of the altercation between Arrizza and his unarmed sufferer.
Really helpful from Editorial
-
Banff homicide suspect appeared intoxicated main as much as deadly bar stabbing: roommate
-
Homicide suspect says sufferer attacked him in washroom of Banff nightclub
-
Banff resident repeatedly stabbed after going to bar restroom throughout evening out with buddy, homicide trial hears
Bigg mentioned that whereas the accused appeared intoxicated by medication or alcohol or each, he wasn’t in such a sophisticated state of intoxication that he couldn’t foresee the results of his assault on Enns-Goneau.
Commercial 4
Article content material
“Your frequent sense tells you, you maintain a knife, you stick it in anyone, this massive of a knife,” he mentioned, holding up the exhibit in courtroom.
“You plan the results.”
Bigg mentioned the variety of wounds and their location supported the Crown’s concept Arrizza murdered Enns-Goneau.
“This reveals a repetitive viciousness,” he mentioned.
“You do it as many occasions as on this case you propose these penalties until that intoxication rises to a degree you can’t respect that.”
Jurors started deliberations late Thursday afternoon after getting closing authorized directions from Justice Robert Corridor.
Article content material