Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the Indian enterprise & finance myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
The author is senior fellow, Peterson Institute for Worldwide Economics, former chief financial adviser to the Indian authorities and adviser to the federal government of Tamil Nadu
India’s rise as a serious financial system has lengthy been held again by its failure to develop a sturdy manufacturing sector. The share of producing in GDP has remained stubbornly low, even declining over the previous decade regardless of the federal government’s huge subsidy programme to encourage companies to “Make in India”. Can this failure be reversed, given the chance created by the stampede of capital away from China?
There are glimmers of hope. One state in southern India — Tamil Nadu — is experiencing a producing increase, attracting the likes of Cisco, Corning, Foxconn, Ford, Google, Tata Electronics and Tata Jaguar Land Rover, and Nike suppliers. These investments are integrating India into international provide chains for electronics, automotives and footwear. What’s the secret to its success?
There’s scope. The state’s manufacturing investments embody a a lot wider vary than elsewhere in India, notably together with labour-intensive actions. That is puzzling, since Tamil Nadu is among the many richest states within the nation. So how can it appeal to labour-intensive manufacturing whereas a lot poorer states can’t? Primarily, as a result of factories have been keen to faucet swimming pools of lower-wage employees, akin to migrants from different Indian states and girls. Actually, 40 per cent of all girls employed in factories in India are in Tamil Nadu.
Then there’s scale. A number of of the brand new initiatives will present employment within the tens of hundreds. That is astonishing in a rustic the place the median agency in labour-intensive industries employs simply 21 employees, making it too small to be globally aggressive.
Tamil Nadu — in contrast to India extra usually — has additionally created the notion that it’s a comparatively simple place to do enterprise. The state has lengthy had a well-developed instructional system, churning out a whole lot of hundreds of engineering graduates yearly. This had made it the nation’s manufacturing powerhouse, particularly in cars and auto elements, which attracted appreciable FDI within the increase years of the noughties. As well as, it affords beneficiant incentives to traders.
However such incentives can be found all through India. The state’s proficient engineers could possibly be employed elsewhere. In Tamil Nadu, nevertheless, the state authorities has additionally grasped the important significance of minimising dangers to traders. There’s a political consensus that after traders arrange store, they shouldn’t be topic to coverage reversals, neglect, or discrimination.
Two examples are illustrative. In 2021, a meals poisoning incident at an electronics plant appeared poised to grow to be a full-scale political incident. The federal government swung into motion, working with each capital and labour. It helped the victims speedily, thereby making certain minimal operational disruption for the employer, and ensured that security requirements had been upgraded.
Additionally in 2021, Ford introduced it wanted to close manufacturing within the state. The Tamil Nadu authorities recognised market realities and helped Ford exit by resolving complicated labour and land points. That have satisfied Ford that dangers of doing enterprise there have been low. So when the corporate determined this 12 months to make a brand new funding in India, it once more selected the southern state. The idea that simple exits incentivise enthusiastic entry has not been simple for Indian policymakers to know.
If India is to develop its manufacturing sector, this Tamil Nadu expertise should be replicated within the poorer, populous heartland states of Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh, with their cheaper labour swimming pools. To make certain, the governance challenges shall be immense and India’s geopolitical window is not going to stay open eternally. However the mannequin is there for emulation.
Josh Felman of Principal JH Consulting contributed to this text
