Indonesia’s coal producers diversify as cash for mining dries up

Unlock the Editor’s Digest without spending a dime

From mine gross sales to enlargement into nickel and aluminium smelting, coal producers in Indonesia are lowering their publicity to the commodity as discovering financing for the “dirtiest” fossil gasoline turns into more and more troublesome.

The south-east Asian nation’s coal capability remains to be rising, and the world’s prime exporter additionally stays one of many largest emitters of carbon, with environmental teams criticising Jakarta for its gradual progress in the direction of greener power sources.

However company efforts to diversify underscore the scrutiny companies at the moment are dealing with amid the power transition and considerations over long-term demand for coal.

“There are clearly rising [environmental, social and governance] pressures, and coal is entrance and centre on this dialogue,” mentioned Ray Gunara, president-director of Harum Vitality, which has been increasing quickly into nickel processing. “It’s very difficult for us to lift any cash for something that’s coal-related. It has been the case for the previous couple of years.”

Harum is one in every of Indonesia’s smaller coal producers, however it’s anticipated to be one of many first to make coal a minority enterprise. It has not put any new funds into coal up to now 5 years. “We now have merely been accumulating money from the present [coal] enterprise and all that money goes into rising our nickel enterprise,” Gunara mentioned.

The corporate plans to shut its coal enterprise when reserves run out in just a few years. “Simply by persevering with enterprise as regular, in six to seven years, the coal enterprise would simply slowly run its course,” Gunara mentioned.

The corporate entered the nickel enterprise in 2020 to faucet into hovering demand for the metallic utilized in electrical automobile batteries. It expects nickel to contribute about 60 per cent of revenues by the top of this yr — a giant soar from 11 per cent final yr — and goals to double manufacturing capability to 150,000 tonnes by the top of 2025.

Different coal producers are additionally transitioning. Indika Vitality has launched electrical motorbikes and solar energy crops and offered some coal mines. It’s aiming to scale back its coal enterprise to 50 per cent of whole revenues by 2025.

Adaro Vitality, run by billionaire Garibaldi Thohir, is constructing an aluminium smelter and a hydro energy plant. Final month, it introduced a plan to spin off its coal enterprise by a public providing valuing it at about $2.5bn.

An evaluation by the Institute for Vitality Economics and Monetary Evaluation exhibits that 5 of the seven main publicly listed Indonesian coal producers are investing in diversification.

“It’s very troublesome to get financing, that’s the most important drawback,” mentioned Ghee Peh, power finance analyst on the IEEFA. Peh added that Adaro’s spin-off technique was a mannequin that could possibly be replicated by its rivals.

Lately, international banks have largely stopped financing coal operations, with Indonesian firms primarily securing financing from home establishments.

Adaro struggled to seek out funds for a $2bn aluminium venture involving a coal energy plant, the Monetary Instances reported final yr, and in April, carmaker Hyundai known as off an aluminium provide settlement with Adaro.

Regardless of diversification efforts, Indonesia’s coal capability remains to be rising and threatens its aim to achieve web zero emissions by 2060.

The federal government banned the development of latest coal energy crops in 2022 however granted a lot of exceptions the place development might nonetheless proceed. New crops will be constructed for unique use inside mineral processing websites and for different tasks deemed as strategic to nationwide pursuits.

The IEEFA’s Peh mentioned two of the seven listed Indonesian coal producers had main enlargement plans that might add an estimated 58mn tonnes of capability. Indonesia produced a report 775mn tonnes of coal final yr.

Coal is accountable for greater than 60 per cent of electrical energy generated in Indonesia, with the nation having ample thermal coal reserves and being the world’s third-largest producer. China, India, Japan and South Korea are among the many prime consumers of Indonesian coal.

Developed nations have promised to supply $22bn in financing by private and non-private funds to assist the nation wean itself off coal. Nonetheless, progress with the distribution of funds has been gradual.

Coal stays a profitable enterprise as costs have climbed lately. Indonesian coal producers noticed report income in 2022. In August, Glencore, the world’s largest publicly listed coal producer, dropped plans to spin off its coal enterprise after traders pushed the corporate to maintain coal for higher returns.

Whereas smaller coal teams can pivot to different sectors extra simply, it could be a problem for others within the business, mentioned Harum’s Gunara. “For a few of our bigger friends, it could be tougher for them to diversify to new areas and rework their coal enterprise right into a minority contributor. It could take a for much longer time.”

Fitch Scores expects funding entry to additional slim within the subsequent three to 5 years. “Corporations that undertake significant diversification methods that transcend thermal coal [will] obtain higher funding entry in contrast with those who preserve conservative monetary profiles with no diversification plans,” the score company instructed the FT.