The Toronto Maple Leafs targeted closely on protection and goaltending in the course of the offseason. But, they’re rumored to be eyeing one other blue-liner to bolster their already improved defensive core. One commerce proposal, submitted by a fan by way of PuckPedia’s PuckGM software, has gained some commentary. This speculative deal would see the Maple Leafs purchase Minnesota Wild defenseman Jake Middleton.
Breaking Down the Proposed Maple Leafs & Wild Commerce
Maple Leafs would obtain Jake Middleton (D). The Wild would obtain Nick Robertson (LW), Timothy Liljegren (D), and a 2027 fourth-round choose. At first look, this deal favors Toronto. Middleton is undoubtedly the most effective participant concerned, including defensive depth and additional solidifying the Maple Leafs’ blue line. Nevertheless, the proposal raises a number of questions when taking a look at Minnesota’s facet. These deal with how invaluable Middleton has develop into to the Wild.
Associated: Little Empathy for Nick Robertson In Maple Leafs Nation
Wanting on the gamers concerned, Middleton, now 28, has quietly blossomed into one of many NHL’s extra dependable defensemen since being traded to the Wild in 2022. In his most up-to-date marketing campaign, he posted 25 factors (7 targets, 18 assists) throughout 80 video games. Whereas his offensive numbers are stable, Middleton’s worth lies in his capacity to play robust, shutdown protection. He has develop into a staple of Minnesota’s defensive core. He has been rewarded for his efforts with a four-year contract extension price $17.4 million. It kicks in after this upcoming season.
Robertson, now 22, is a gifted winger who has had a rocky begin to his profession. That’s primarily as a consequence of accidents and inconsistent alternatives. In 56 NHL video games, Robertson has scored 27 factors (14 targets, 13 assists). He has requested a commerce and is reportedly looking for a contemporary begin the place he might probably earn extra ice time and play a extra important offensive function. Robertson might slide right into a middle-six ahead place for Minnesota and provide potential scoring depth.
Liljegren, now 25, is a former first-round choose with stable defensive instincts and the power to contribute offensively. He has registered 65 factors (14 targets, 51 assists) in 196 profession video games. Nevertheless, regardless of his potential, he has struggled to cement himself as a top-four defenseman in Toronto absolutely. In Minnesota, Liljegren might exchange Middleton on the blue line, offering youth and potential upside to a crew that values depth on protection.
Middleton’s Rise in Minnesota: Why Commerce Him Now?
This proposal’s most obvious weak point considerations why the Wild would think about parting methods with Middleton. Moreover, there’s no purpose why Middleton would wish to go away. Since becoming a member of the Wild in 2022, he has develop into essential to their defensive id. His grit, physicality, and shutdown capacity have made him a fan favourite, and his sport has solely improved below the Wild’s system.
Furthermore, Middleton is below contract via the 2028-29 season, making him a chunk of Minnesota’s future. His latest four-year extension speaks volumes about how extremely the Wild’s entrance workplace values him. After signing the deal, Middleton mentioned, “We love the crew, we love the whole lot about Minnesota… we simply couldn’t be happier to get this completed.” The participant and the group are aligned on his future with the Wild.
So why would any rumors of a commerce make sense? Fairly merely, they don’t. For the Wild, buying and selling a defenseman within the prime of his profession who’s locked right into a team-friendly deal appears counterintuitive. Whereas Robertson and Liljegren provide some promise, they don’t fill rapid wants for the Wild, particularly with the departure of a confirmed defenseman like Middleton.
Does the Commerce Profit the Maple Leafs?
From the Toronto Maple Leafs’ perspective, buying Middleton can be a win. He would solidify the crew’s protection, probably slotting right into a second-pairing function and taking stress off their prime pairing. Nevertheless, the price of giving up Nick Robertson and Timothy Liljegren, plus a future draft choose, is doable.
Whereas Robertson’s time in Toronto may finish quickly, Liljegren’s future stays unsure. At 25, he’s nonetheless creating, and whereas he hasn’t lived as much as the expectations of a first-round choose, he might nonetheless evolve right into a dependable top-four defenseman. Toronto’s choice to incorporate him in such a commerce would hinge on how they consider his potential shifting ahead.
The Backside Line: Does this Commerce Make Sense? No!
For the Maple Leafs, buying Middleton would considerably strengthen their protection. For the Wild, buying and selling Middleton, who has thrived of their system and signed a long-term extension, is tough to justify. He’s develop into a core a part of their defensive lineup, and shifting him for belongings that don’t instantly meet their wants appears questionable.
Except unknown components stew beneath the floor, it’s tough to see why the Wild would half with a participant so integral to their future plans.
Associated: Craig Berube’s Teaching Model: A New Voice Was Wanted
