Again in September, The Athletic’s NFL employees made picks for MVP, Tremendous Bowl champion and extra. Two months later, the season’s (approximate) midseason level, is the proper time to replace these predictions. Some issues remained the identical (just like the consensus Tremendous Bowl LIX matchup), whereas others have modified (MVP and Tremendous Bowl winner picks).
Forty-six staffers responded. Listed below are their predictions.
Voter fatigue might need been a think about Lamar Jackson drawing zero MVP votes in our ballot two months in the past, however his efficiency thus far has been plain. Patrick Mahomes was the decide earlier than the season began, however whereas he’s been higher than his box-score statline would counsel he might need too steep a statistical hill to climb to overhaul Jackson.
GO DEEPER
NFL midseason predictions for each workforce: Kirk Cousins wins comeback award; NFC East champ is …?
Like his quarterback teammate who now leads the MVP race, Derrick Henry didn’t draw a single OPOY vote from our employees within the preseason, although Henry now appears to be a wholesome second half of the season away from clinching the award for a second time in his profession. The 2 high vote-getters in September have been achieved in by accidents — Tyreek Hill to his quarterback, and Christian McCaffrey to himself.
Watt completed third within the preseason vote, behind Micah Parsons and Myles Garrett. Parsons’ harm and Garrett’s (comparatively) down season have swung the door open for Watt to win DPOY honors for a second time — which might put him one trophy away from catching large brother J.J., a three-time winner with the Houston Texans. Warner and Chris Jones additionally drew votes in September’s ballot.
GO DEEPER
2024 NFL commerce deadline winners, losers: Chiefs, Lions get richer; why did Giants keep put?
Jayden Daniels completed second to the draft’s high decide, Caleb Williams, within the preseason vote. Although whereas Williams’ play has improved because the season has gone on, Daniels has been spectacular and is primarily answerable for the staggering turnaround of the Commanders’ on-field fortunes. (Additionally, whereas we didn’t cut up the rookie vote into Offensive and Defensive awards just like the NFL does, one voter did spotlight Rams edge rusher Jared Verse as the highest defensive rookie.)
The Chiefs drew 28 of 42 votes (67 %) to win the AFC in September, and now get an analogous share (63 %) at midseason. They’ve run into some harm points (particularly high receiver Rashee Rice) coming off a 21-game season a yr in the past, however with an ideal document issues are set as much as run via Kansas Metropolis within the AFC playoffs. There’s not a lot purpose to maneuver off the two-time defending champs.
GO DEEPER
NFL Coach of the 12 months, MVP and largest surprises (and disappointments) at midseason
Whereas the Lions have been the preseason decide with lower than half the vote (16 of 42, 38 %), their efficiency within the first half of the season, particularly of late, has made them heavy favorites within the NFC (87 % of the vote). The Packers, 49ers and Eagles have been second, third, and fourth, respectively, in September as effectively.
Free, day by day NFL updates direct to your inbox.
Free, day by day NFL updates direct to your inbox.
Signal Up
Whereas the 2 convention champion picks held from the summer season, the Lions have received over the employees’s confidence relating to doubtlessly lifting the Lombardi Trophy after Tremendous Bowl LIX. Whereas the Chiefs obtained greater than half the vote (23 of 42) in September, Detroit drew solely two votes to win the Tremendous Bowl earlier than the season began, tied for fifth (behind the Chiefs, 49ers, Texans and Bengals) at the moment.
What they mentioned
“The Dolphins are flawed on protection and might’t afford greater than two extra losses, however they’ve obtained a supercharged offense and the conducive schedule (Rams, Raiders, Patriots, Browns, Jets twice) to go on a run and steal the AFC’s seventh playoff spot.” — Joe Buscaglia, Payments beat author
“It’s the 49ers in the event that they get Christian McCaffrey again and he’s capable of keep on the sector. In any other case, I’d go along with the Bengals.” — Mike Sando, NFL senior author
“I nearly picked the 49ers to win the NFC regardless of their 4-4 begin. They’ve performed shorthanded all season, and whereas they’re not getting Brandon Aiyuk or Javon Hargrave again I believe they’ve sufficient elsewhere to win all of it if issues break proper. Brock Purdy has taken one other step, and the offensive line has extra upside than in earlier years. If Christian McCaffrey will get proper, San Francisco could possibly be a juggernaut once more.” — David DeChant, senior editor
“The Rams are in a weak division, and the offense is getting wholesome.” — R.J. Kraft, employees editor
GO DEEPER
2025 NFL mock draft: What number of QBs crack the highest 10? Is Travis Hunter well worth the No. 1 decide?
What they mentioned
“Doug Pederson is beneath essentially the most strain; Jaguars possession publicly set expectations so excessive coming into the season.” — Mike Sando, NFL senior author
“It’d already be unsalvageable in Dallas, however there’s no means Jerry Jones can flip again to Mike McCarthy if this factor goes additional off the rails.” — Jim Ayello, senior editor
“You simply don’t bench a 22-year-old quarterback who was the fourth total decide for his 39-year-old backup if you happen to aren’t all-in on this yr.” — Joe Buscaglia, Payments beat author
(Illustration: Dan Goldfarb / The Athletic; pictures: Sam Hodde / Getty Pictures, Patrick McDermott / Getty Pictures, Cooper Neill / Getty Pictures)
