“To beat with out danger is to triumph with out glory,” as Pierre Corneille wrote in his traditional tragicomedy Le Cid. Thus on Sunday, Emmanuel Macron received the French presidential election with none glory.
The elections themselves have misplaced their conventional spark and sense of jousting. The ultimate debate between Macron and Marine Le Pen was a debate between technical managers with out a grand imaginative and prescient for France. Each need to write cheques that France can’t money. And this second-round match up was merely what had been anticipated for years, regardless of transient bursts of hypothesis that one other candidate – Éric Zemmour (far-right), Valérie Pécresse (centrist) and even Jean-Luc Mélenchon (far-left) – would possibly edge out Le Pen.
Nonetheless, the elections introduced some surprises. First, the anti-establishment events represented by Melenchon, Zemmour and Le Pen have change into mainstream, gathering greater than half of voters who’re extraordinarily dissatisfied. The causes of their miscontent vary from a lack of social id to dwindling buying energy, and from heavy taxation to administration of the Covid-19 disaster. After I met Marine Le Pen final December in Warsaw, she offered herself extra as a traditional left-wing candidate than a consultant of the precise. She left the subject of migration and id to Zemmour. She vowed to guard the French working class towards globalisation and to deal with buying energy. This was instinct, permitting her to be within the second spherical as soon as once more and to extend her share of the vote from 33.9% in 2017 to 41.5% now.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek right now and get your first six journal points completely FREE
Get 6 points free
Signal as much as Cash Morning
Do not miss the most recent funding and private funds information, market evaluation, plus money-saving ideas with our free twice-daily e-newsletter
Do not miss the most recent funding and private funds information, market evaluation, plus money-saving ideas with our free twice-daily e-newsletter
Therefore another view of the presidential elections is that three left events have gathered three-quarters of voters within the first spherical: Le Pen (23.2%), Melenchon (22%) and Macron (27.9%) – it shouldn’t be forgotten that he was finance minister below leftist president François Hollande earlier than creating his personal motion to run for president in 2017. Un carnage a trois. Can le déclin français ever be stopped?
Twenty years of decline
Within the mid Nineties, French trade was in a position to compete towards German trade, whereas Paris was battling with London to be the monetary hub of Europe. However France was unable to reform its social system: wide-ranging strikes and protests in 1995 pressured prime minister Alain Juppé to desert his proposed reforms. At this time, social spending represents a report 31% of GDP (the comparable determine for the UK and for the OECD common is round 20%), of which half is represented by pensions. It’s a world report and “a loopy quantity of dough”, as Macron identified.
The standard strengths of France – primarily its infrastructure, just a few multinational large-cap firms and its agriculture sector, have weakened considerably. The pandemic and up to date scandals associated to care properties have highlighted the weaknesses of the healthcare system. In training, France has plunged steadily within the OECD’s programme for worldwide scholar evaluation (Pisa) rating, as a result of the training system promotes equality and rejects choice, which aligns pupils with the weakest. French academics are reportedly stunned by the relative wonderful degree of maths amongst Ukrainian refugees. This doesn’t bode properly for the way forward for the nation. The justice system is in need of funds… one may go on. Contemplating this lack of investments in key sectors, one wonders what the heavy degree of taxation is for.
The euro worsens France’s lack of competitiveness, as a result of it’s unable to devalue its foreign money. The euro was tailor-made for the German economic system whereas the “Membership Med” economies (Greece, Italy, Spain, and certainly France) had been pacified with excessively low rates of interest. The French economic system is now within the second league – its trade is struggling to compete with rejuvenated Spain and rising Jap Europe. Trade represents 16.5% of GDP, even lower than within the UK (17% of GDP), even if the latter is usually offered because the nation with no remaining trade.
Macron did not ship
Again in 2017, Macron consciously aspired to be a “Jupiterian” president – an aloof determine with god-like powers to reform France. An inexperienced parliament voted at his command, approving legal guidelines usually late at evening as soon as most MPs had been house. Most ministers remained unknown, besides those caught in some scandals. However regardless of promising to be a revolutionary, he seems to be extra of a administration advisor, primarily involved along with his picture and having fun with his energy.
Admittedly, he confronted some challenges: the gilets jaunes protest motion, the pandemic (though this allowed him to current himself as a warfare chief) and now Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. And to be honest, he initially took some good choices. He maintained the crédit d’impôt pour la compétitivité et l’emploi (CICE), a tax credit score to advertise competitiveness and employment launched by his hapless predecessor Hollande. He capped capital features tax at 30% and decreased company tax from 33.3% to 25%. These reforms had been extremely vital. Different taxes such because the contribution sociale généralisée (CSG), to fund the welfare system, and inexperienced taxes had been elevated.
Pre-pandemic financial development was near 2% per 12 months on common, barely above its common since 2000. GDP can also be anticipated to recuperate its pre-pandemic ranges this primary half of the 12 months. GDP development this 12 months is anticipated to be 2.9%, consistent with the eurozone, though falling to its long-term pattern of 1.4% in 2023. Unemployment decreased from 9.4% to 7.6%. Even now, inflation stays comparatively contained in contrast with the remainder of Europe at 4.5% as a result of some vitality and electrical energy costs are capped. Buying energy – the theme on the core of the election – truly elevated yearly by 1% over the previous 5 years for these within the backside decile, in response to the OECD.
Macron has additionally inspired entrepreneurship and hubs of innovation, below the flag “start-up nation”. A €10bn public fund was created to finance disruptive innovation. French tech corporations raised €4.8bn in the course of the first quarter of 2022. Nevertheless, Paris has failed to draw monetary companies from the UK after Brexit. Firms choose to checklist in Amsterdam, for instance.
A rustic hooked on public spending
Macron’s slight discount in taxation was unfunded. He was unable to curb public spending that handed 60% of GDP because the funds deficit exploded to six.9% in 2021. A few of this pertains to distinctive bills in the course of the pandemic, however indebtedness is spiralling uncontrolled to €2.8trn or 113% of GDP (a complete rise of €700bn throughout Macron’s presidency). France is hooked on public spending: the final time the nation achieved a funds surplus was 1974. Again in that period, former president Valéry Giscard D’Estaing declared that if public spending reached 40% of GDP, the nation could possibly be thought of socialist – it’s far past that now. Debt and taxes are extreme and weigh considerably on the competitiveness of firms.
The commerce deficit has elevated to €85bn per 12 months as France exports much less and fewer: automotive manufacturing has greater than halved over the previous 20 years. From being a robust exporter within the nineties, France has not been in a position to report a commerce surplus since 2005, and the pattern is alarming. (The deficit is anticipated to exceed €100bn this 12 months, partly attributable to increased commodity costs.) It has even change into a web importer of meals, apart from spirits and wine). An agriculture sector crushed below heavy laws and taxation can not compete with imports. Of that €85bn deficit, €57bn outcomes from commerce inside the eurozone, telling us {that a} lack of competitiveness with neighbours is in charge, reasonably than China or vitality imports. The deficit with Germany exceeds €30bn, practically twice the one with China, displaying how Germany has been in a position to revenue from naivety relating to the French-German relationship. France’s general present account deficit that features each items and companies reached €25.8bn final 12 months.
Extra worryingly, company indebtedness reveals no signal of lower at 82% of GDP. This compares to 51% in Germany or 59% within the UK, and makes firms extra weak in a possible financial downturn led by excessive commodity costs. The European Central Financial institution (ECB) is below strain to normalise rates of interest as inflation is surging – producer value inflation (PPI) in Germany reached a staggering 30% in March – which might improve finance prices. This comes at a time when the dangers of a full embargo or halt on Russian oil and fuel is rising, which may push oil costs to $185 per barrel, reckons JP Morgan. That may put additional strain on company margins.
One other hit from Russia
Regardless of this, the French stockmarket has completed higher than you would possibly assume. Over the previous 5 years, the CAC 40 index elevated by 25%, twice the achieve within the Dax 30, whereas the FTSE 100 stays flat. Nevertheless, some long-standing French champions comparable to Renault are dealing with sturdy headwinds. Renault went via numerous crises over the previous 5 years and is now on the level the place its market capitalisation is smaller than the worth of its stake in Nissan. To make issues far worse, its second-largest market after France is Russia. Or extra precisely, it was Russia: Renault will offload its 68% stake in Avtovaz, maker of the Lada, for a symbolic €1. Extra painful than the instant loss is the price by way of future economic system of scale that has helped assist the exceptional success of its Dacia division (Dacia-derived fashions are made and offered in Russia) and should weigh on its alliance with Nissan.
Renault isn’t alone. Many French firms have already made provisions for billions of euros in losses relating to their actions in Russia. It’s unlucky that finance minister Bruno Le Maire, who declared all-out financial and monetary warfare on Russia in February, inspired French firms to spend money on Russia firstly of Macron’s time period. Circumstances have modified, however it illustrates how French politicians lack imaginative and prescient (British politicians have, in fact, carried out the identical shameless and unacknowledged about-turn). Now Auchan, Decathlon, LVMH, Société Générale and Complete are all below strain to shut or give away their actions in Russia. One wonders who’s punished essentially the most by these sanctions.
Priorities for a second time period
Macron can declare that he has as soon as once more saved democracy by beating Le Pen, however his programme is uninspiring even in contrast with 2017. Measures to enhance girls’s well being, finish the TV licence and sort out on-line harassment is not going to change France. There can be €15bn in annual tax cuts – not appreciated by native authorities that see their incomes lower (decreased council tax and territorial financial contribution paid by companies). Some €35bn can be spent on key sectors comparable to the military, training and justice. Regardless of these bills and an anticipated improve in rates of interest (and thus debt-servicing prices), the general public deficit is someway anticipated to be lower than 3% of GDP in 2027.
Essentially the most attention-grabbing factors of his programme are the surroundings, agriculture and clear vitality, particularly offshore wind vitality and nuclear vitality. He has additionally vowed to regulate the European Fee’s “Farm to Fork” meals technique, which was set to scale back agricultural manufacturing by 13%.
Above all, Macron should reform the pension system. The important process of suspending the retirement age to 65 is supported by his electoral base though they’re older and nearer to retirement. Nevertheless, he should be cautious to not exacerbate the social divide with a few of his calculated provocations. One a part of France is flourishing with globalisation – pensioners, inhabitants of metropoles (city areas) and enormous elements of the general public sector. The opposite half – the younger and the agricultural – is marginalised. Thus 60% of the younger supported Le Pen, whereas 70% of pensioners supported Macron.
Elections to the Nationwide Meeting (the decrease home of parliament), which are sometimes referred to as the third spherical of the presidential elections, are due in June. Nevertheless, they might be introduced ahead to keep up Macron’s momentum. The result is unsure – he might not have a majority. The id of the prime minister – who’s appointed by the president however should have the assist of the Nationwide Meeting – is anybody’s guess. Macron might must cope with a robust left that will block pension reform. Conversely, the right-wing Les Républicains might do properly regardless of the humiliation of their candidate Pécresse, (who received simply 4.79%) and will assist Macron’s proposals.
One of the best of the CAC 40 and past
Defence firms Thales (Paris: HO) and Dassault (Paris: DSY) have seen their shares rise dramatically this 12 months and the shares at the moment are expensive. The world is investing closely in weaponry, however Nato nations that plan to extend spending, comparable to Germany and Poland, have a tendency to purchase American fighters or weapons reasonably than French. Mining and metals agency Eramet (Paris: ERA), lengthy seen as struggling, has additionally seen its worth practically double for the reason that starting of the 12 months due to the commodity increase.
Clear vitality might be a greater place to look. However Renault’s (Paris: RNO) Russian catastrophe, be aware that the agency plans to spin off its electrical arm (like Volvo with Polestar) within the hope of attaining a Tesla-like valuation. Moreover, Macron promised extra subsidies for the leasing of electrical automobiles. That would profit leasing firm ALD (Paris: ALD). Renewable vitality corporations Volatalia (Paris: VLTSA) and Neoen (Paris: Neoen) will profit from elevated funding within the sector.
Macron has additionally emphasised vitality preservation and home insulation. That can favour an organization comparable to Rexel (Paris: RXL), which distributes a variety of kit, together with renewable vitality and vitality effectivity merchandise. It appears to be like low cost on an enterprise worth/earnings earlier than curiosity, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EV/Ebitda) of seven.5.
Oil main Complete stays low cost due to its publicity to Russia. Being pressured handy over its property can be extraordinarily pricey. I choose Vallourec (Paris: VK), which supplies pipes for the oil enterprise and is down considerably during the last two years. Additionally contemplate CGG (Paris: CGG), which does seismic surveying for oil explorers, in addition to oil agency Maurel et Promenade (Paris: MAU), which is concentrated on exploration.
Luxurious items corporations comparable to LVMH (Paris: MC) and Hermès (Paris: RMS) profit from the worldwide rise in inequality. They’re among the many largest listed French firms, together with magnificence large L’Oréal (Paris: OR). The sector stays sturdy and LVMH reported report gross sales of €62bn in 2021. That stated, it’s not clearly low cost: its smaller peer Kering (Paris: KER) is valued at a extra enticing ratio.
Sturdy meals manufacturers are in a position to switch inflationary strain to clients to protect their margins. Danone (Paris: BN) has delivered many disappointing years however appears to be like enticing now on an EV/Ebitda ratio of ten. Fleury Michon (Paris: ALFLE), a specialist in meats and prepared meals, is on an EV/Ebitda of 5.
Healthcare and prescription drugs are a key sector: packaged medicines symbolize 6% of French international exports. Many medical exams and coverings have been postponed attributable to lockdowns and the deal with Covid-19. Guerbet (Paris: GBT), which makes distinction brokers utilized in medical imaging, may benefit from a rebound in screening, as may diagnostics agency Eurobio Scientific (Paris: ALERS). Medical-stage biotech agency Acticor Biotech (Paris: ALACT), which focuses on remedy of thrombotic illnesses, can also be an attention-grabbing one to look at.