On September 13, 2018, the Ottawa Senators made probably the most vital strikes in latest franchise historical past by buying and selling their star defenseman Erik Karlsson to the San Jose Sharks. Karlsson, a two-time Norris Trophy winner and one of many NHL’s elite defensemen, had been the guts of the Senators’ blue line for practically a decade.
In return, Ottawa obtained a package deal of gamers and draft picks, signaling the beginning of a rebuild. Two gamers who got here to the Senators on account of the commerce have been Josh Norris and Tim Stützle. Each stay with the group.
However, over six years later, how did the commerce play out for each side? Right here’s a more in-depth take a look at the important thing items concerned within the commerce and who might have finally received the deal.
Erik Karlsson Grew to become a Famous person for San Jose
Karlsson joined the Sharks as probably the most dynamic offensive defensemen within the league. The Sharks hoped he could be the ultimate piece to push them towards a Stanley Cup. Karlsson did assist the group make a deep playoff run in his first season. Nevertheless, accidents and inconsistency plagued his tenure in San Jose.
Regardless of these setbacks, Karlsson’s expertise was by no means in query. He loved a renaissance yr within the 2022-23 season, exhibiting he can nonetheless be a dominant pressure on the ice. Nevertheless, Karlsson’s massive contract proved pricey, with the Sharks not in rivalry. His tenure in San Jose didn’t meet its lofty expectations. Whereas he carried out at a excessive degree individually, the Sharks didn’t attain the success they envisioned once they acquired him. He was moved to Pittsburgh in 2023.
Josh Norris: A Potential Future Star for Ottawa?
Ottawa obtained a younger participant within the commerce, Josh Norris, a prospect who had but to play an NHL sport. Norris made his NHL debut with the Senators within the 2019-20 season, showing in three video games with out registering some extent. His breakout got here within the 2020-21 season. He performed 56 video games, scoring 17 targets and including 18 assists for 35 factors.
Norris took one other leap in 2021-22, scoring a powerful 35 targets and 20 assists for 55 factors in 66 video games. Sadly, accidents restricted him to eight video games within the 2022-23 season, the place he managed two targets and one help. He rebounded in 2023-24, enjoying 50 video games and contributing 16 targets and 14 assists for 30 factors.
Tim Stützle: The Commerce’s Recreation-Changer
Maybe the largest prize Ottawa obtained within the Karlsson commerce was a conditional first-round decide. That decide was Tim Stützle, who was drafted third total in 2020. Stützle has quickly developed into one of many NHL’s brightest younger stars.
Stützle’s affect on the Senators was quick. After becoming a member of the Senators within the 2020-21 season, he performed 53 video games and recorded 12 targets and 17 assists for 29 factors. He took a major step ahead in 2021-22. That season, he performed 79 video games and elevated his manufacturing to 22 targets and 36 assists for 58 factors.
Stützle’s breakout got here within the 2022-23 season, the place he scored 39 targets and added 51 assists for a powerful 90 factors in 78 video games. In 2023-24, he continued to indicate his playmaking potential, scoring 18 targets and 52 assists for 70 factors in 75 video games. Within the 2024-25 season, Stützle began robust with two targets in his first sport.
The Senators Obtained Different Items: DeMelo, Tierney, and Draft Picks
Along with Norris and Stützle, Ottawa obtained defenseman Dylan DeMelo and ahead Chris Tierney. DeMelo supplied strong play on the Senators’ blue line earlier than being traded to the Winnipeg Jets. There, he’s develop into a serviceable blue liner. Tierney performed 4 seasons with the Senators and was a flexible two-way ahead. He now performs within the KHL after stops with Florida and New Jersey.
The Senators additionally obtained a number of draft picks. One was used to pick Zack Ostapchuk, a promising younger ahead who continues to develop of their system. Within the 2023-24 season, Ostapchuk performed seven video games for the Senators however didn’t register any factors. Nevertheless, he had a extra productive season with the Belleville Senators within the AHL, scoring 17 targets and including 11 assists for 28 factors in 69 video games. He additionally contributed two factors in six playoff video games.
Who Gained the Commerce?
From a short-term perspective, the Sharks initially appeared to learn from buying Karlsson. He helped them attain the 2019 Western Convention Closing. Nevertheless, Karlsson’s hefty contract and damage historical past hindered San Jose in later years, and the group has been unable to maintain success.
Lengthy-term, it’s more and more clear that the Senators are the winners of this commerce. Norris and Stützle are already key items of the group’s core, with the potential to be stars for a few years. Karlsson, whereas nonetheless an elite participant, is approaching the twilight of his profession enjoying in Pittsburgh with the Penguins. Ottawa’s younger expertise is simply starting to emerge.
The actual kicker for Ottawa is Stützle. If he continues his trajectory, the commerce might be considered as a franchise-defining second, setting the Senators up for sustained success sooner or later.
The Backside Line? The Senators Got here Out Forward on This Commerce
Whereas San Jose may need initially received the participant they wanted, Ottawa’s long-term rewards make them the winners of the Karlsson commerce. With Norris and Stützle a part of the group’s core group, the Senators are poised to be aggressive for years. The choice to commerce their franchise defenseman was a sensible transfer for the longer term.
Associated: Swayman and Ullmark Offers Will Impression Oettinger’s Talks in Dallas
