Be a part of our every day and weekly newsletters for the newest updates and unique content material on industry-leading AI protection. Study Extra
Elon Musk’s publicly traded electrical car firm Tesla, Inc. hosted its extremely anticipated “We Robotic” occasion on Oct. 10, 2024, at Warner Bros. Discovery Studios in Burbank, California and streamed it reside on his social community X and YouTube.
Regardless of exhibiting off slick prototypes of a brand new “Cybercab” autonomous automotive with out a steering wheel or fuel and brake pedals, and a equally sparse, artwork deco retrofuturistic “Robovan” able to seating 20 passengers, the occasion was criticized by some outstanding observers as being extra fashion than substance. lt was missing in exact particulars on timelines, prices and authorized points, and even got here throughout as deceptive in some circumstances.
Essentially the most obvious instance of doubtless deceptive info was Tesla’s transfer to have its still-in-development humanoid Optimus robots filling the venue house and interacting with attendees, even serving drinks at a bar. Whereas some current assumed the robots have been totally autonomous, studies confirmed they have been teleoperated — that means managed by a human in one other room.
“Not wholly AI? By no means AI,” wrote enterprise capitalist Josh Wolfe, co-founder of Lux Capital on Musk’s social community X. “Completely worthy to have a good time low latency distant management however completely dishonest to demo these as autonomous robots—name it the parlor trick it’s.”
This skepticism raises questions on how far Tesla has really superior in creating synthetic intelligence for robotics. Whereas Musk touted the Optimus, Cybercab and Robotaxi as tremendously impactful innovations for society, EV reviewers The Kilowatts famous on X that a lot of the expertise will stay “unbelievable” to buyers and customers till it’s shipped.
For now, Tesla’s imaginative and prescient of totally autonomous private robots in addition to new autonomous electrical car sorts stays extra speculative than practical. Right here’s a abstract of what was mentioned:
Cybercab: all autonomous and cheaper than a bus or Mannequin 3?
Maybe essentially the most anticipated of the bulletins was Tesla’s Cybercab, a two-seater electrical car designed for autonomous operation.
Musk described the Cybercab as a modern, extra compact model of the Cybertruck, and it’ll reportedly value lower than $30,000. That’s beneath the present value of Tesla’s most reasonably priced private car, the Mannequin 3, which debuted at $35,000 in 2019 however has since seen its value rise to round $42,000.
In line with Musk, Tesla goals for the Cybercab’s working value to be between $0.20 and $0.30 per mile in comparison with the operational value of a bus, which he positioned at round $1 per mile.
The autos could be powered by inductive (wi-fi) charging, eliminating the necessity for plug-in charging stations and additional integrating autonomous automobiles into the city panorama.
The promise of an individualized “mass transit” future has lengthy been a part of Musk’s imaginative and prescient, and the Cybercab is a key part of that objective.
Through the occasion, Musk proudly displayed 20 Cybercabs driving autonomously across the venue. He emphasised that the Cybercab is a part of a broader effort to make cities safer, cleaner and extra environment friendly.
Tesla’s AI Imaginative and prescient system, educated on hundreds of thousands of automobiles, permits these autos to function with out the fatigue and distractions that have an effect on human drivers. Musk claimed that Tesla’s autonomous expertise might finally make driving 10 to 30 occasions safer than human operation.
He additionally floated the concept that autonomous automotive homeowners might handle fleets of autos, providing ride-hailing companies just like Uber or Lyft. This enterprise mannequin, if profitable, might reshape the gig financial system and create new alternatives for people to generate earnings.
Nevertheless, whereas the Cybercab’s debut was met with enthusiasm, {industry} insiders raised considerations concerning the lack of concrete particulars surrounding its rollout.
Musk indicated that manufacturing on the Cybercab would start between “most likely” in 2026 or “earlier than 2027,” however admitted he “have a tendency[ed] to be a bit of optimistic with timeframes.”
Certainly, Tesla has traditionally struggled with assembly deadlines for its extra bold initiatives corresponding to its Full Self-Driving (FSD) and even transport the Cybertruck, which Musk at one level prompt could be waterproof sufficient to behave as a ship for brief journeys (it isn’t and can’t).
As Washington Submit expertise journalist Faiz Siddiqui famous on X, the whole We, Robotic occasion livestream was preceded by a heavy disclaimer from Tesla stating, partly, that “Ahead-looking statements are primarily based on assumptions with respect to the longer term, are primarily based on administration’s present expectations, contain sure dangers and uncertainties, and will not be ensures. Future outcomes could differ materially from these expressed in any forward-looking assertion.”
Whereas the imaginative and prescient of reasonably priced autonomous transportation is compelling, a lot stays unsure about when—or if—Tesla can ship on these guarantees.
Robovan: Tesla’s reply to buses, trains, and mass transit
One other key reveal on the occasion was Tesla’s Robovan, a big autonomous car designed to move as much as 20 passengers or items.
Musk positioned the Robovan as a possible resolution for high-density city transport, hinting at a future the place autonomous shuttles exchange standard buses.
The Robovan represents a imaginative and prescient of extra environment friendly, much less congested cities the place autonomous autos run regularly sufficient to eradicate the necessity for giant, underutilized parking heaps.
Musk prompt that, over time, cities might convert parking areas into parks, bettering the standard of life in city areas.
Some expertise observers corresponding to Brian Roemmele on X have been overjoyed on the information, particularly the Robovan’s modern, putting artwork deco design, even predicting that “100s of 1000s” or a whole lot of 1000’s of individuals could be dwelling in Robovans transformed into cellular properties by 2031.
Regardless of these bold targets and reward, critics have been fast to level out that Tesla provided no particular timeline for the Robovan’s manufacturing.
X consumer Information Chaser famous that whereas Tesla unveiled a prototype, China already has operational autonomous vans in actual city environments.
Tesla Full Self-Driving coming to Texas and California subsequent 12 months?
A recurring theme on the We Robotic occasion was Musk’s long-held perception that autonomous autos will revolutionize city life by decreasing site visitors, bettering security and reclaiming public areas.
Tesla’s plans to launch totally unsupervised Full Self-Driving (FSD) in Texas and California by 2025 have been highlighted as a pivotal second on this transformation.
The rollout will start with the Mannequin 3 and Mannequin Y, adopted by the Cybertruck and finally the Cybercab.
Musk painted an image of a future the place autonomous autos are used as much as ten occasions extra regularly than right this moment’s automobiles, dramatically growing their worth.
Nevertheless, regardless of Musk’s optimism, a number of hurdles stay. Tesla has confronted important regulatory challenges in deploying its FSD expertise, and autonomous driving expertise basically has not but reached the Degree 4 autonomy obligatory for autos to function with out human oversight.
Optimus: your future family helper?
Tesla’s Optimus humanoid robotic additionally took heart stage on the occasion. Musk launched the robotic as a private assistant able to performing on a regular basis duties like babysitting, strolling canines, mowing lawns, and even serving drinks at events.
The robotic was showcased interacting with and talking with attendees, even bartending and taking part in halting video games of “rock, paper, scissors” impressing many with its potential versatility.
In line with Musk, at scale, Optimus might be offered for $20,000 to $30,000, making it a attainable addition to hundreds of thousands of households.
Nevertheless, he once more supplied no particular timeline for its launch, nor publicly answered questions on how the robotic would deal with adversarial conditions like a canine or baby operating away, breaking one thing, or inflicting different issues and mischief, not to mention guaranteeing the robotic would have the ability to deal with stated widespread conditions safely and with out harming others within the course of.
In the meantime, different robotics suppliers corresponding to startup Determine, 1X (each backed by OpenAI), and many newcomers from China are pursuing their very own humanoid robotic helpers for the house, establishing an intense contest. Nevertheless, Tesla has proven itself to be proof against challengers within the EV market and continues to develop market share, making the outlook for Optimus probably extra bullish.
Security, authorized and regulatory challenges stay
One of many greatest challenges going through Tesla because it pushes for widespread adoption of autonomous autos and robots is regulatory approval.
Whereas Musk’s imaginative and prescient of autonomous transport is daring, it’s fraught with authorized and security considerations.
Automobiles just like the Cybercab, which lack steering wheels and pedals, might want to adjust to strict security requirements earlier than they are often offered or used on public roads.
Tesla’s present FSD expertise has already come below scrutiny from regulators following a number of high-profile accidents involving Tesla autos working below partial autonomy.
For Tesla to attain Degree 4 autonomy—the place a car can function with out human intervention below particular circumstances—it might want to show that its methods can reliably deal with a variety of driving eventualities with out placing passengers or pedestrians in danger.
Spammers make the most of the eye
The We Robotic occasion attracted important on-line consideration, although the livestream was marred by a flood of bots and spammers selling an unrelated cryptocurrency token, XAI33x.
Regardless of the disruption, Tesla followers have been usually enthusiastic concerning the future Musk offered, though many have been left with lingering doubts concerning the timelines and feasibility of a number of the bulletins.
