When mega-politics collide with mega-projects, chaos ensues
Article content material
What will get constructed first, the Keystone XL pipeline or Calgary’s Inexperienced Line LRT venture?
One venture is lifeless and buried — colder than super-chilled LNG — and the opposite seems to be on the ropes.
They’re very completely different developments — cross-border power infrastructure in comparison with public transit — however each show what occurs when mega-politics collide with mega-projects: chaos.
Commercial 2
Article content material
Premier Danielle Smith was requested by reporters about the way forward for each tasks this week after talking on the Lloydminster Heavy Oil Present.
Because the oilpatch sees file manufacturing this yr, due partially to the startup of the Trans Mountain Growth, ideas concerning the want for future transportation capability out of Western Canada are returning.
Greater than a decade in the past, Keystone XL was seen as a essential a part of the answer to this downside.
The event proposed by TransCanada (later renamed TC Vitality) was anticipated to ship 830,000 barrels of Western Canadian oil southward, connecting the oilsands to the large refining hub alongside the U.S. Gulf Coast.
Amid political sniping south of the border, Keystone XL grew to become a wedge concern between Democrats and Republicans in a debate pitting local weather towards the financial system.
Its cross-border allow was cancelled by U.S. President Joe Biden on his first day in workplace in 2021, though it had been permitted by his predecessor, Donald Trump. Earlier than that, it was beforehand rejected by then-president Barack Obama final decade.
Development was already underway, with the backing of the Alberta authorities, when the venture was halted. TC later took an enormous write-down. The province was left to soak up an estimated $1.3-billion lack of taxpayer cash.
Midday Information Roundup
Article content material
Commercial 3
Article content material
KXL was lifeless. So why is Keystone XL even being mentioned once more?
On this week’s presidential candidates’ debate, Trump raised the moribund venture whereas attacking his Democratic rival, U.S. Vice-President Kamala Harris, over power and worldwide affairs.
Trump needs to see extra power infrastructure constructed, whereas there seems to be little likelihood Harris would overturn Biden’s choice.
Extra importantly, it’s unlikely any CEO or board of administrators would wade into this minefield and suggest a revamped KXL 2.0.
Throughout a hearth chat on the oil present, when Smith was requested about the opportunity of Keystone XL being resurrected, she identified that current pipeline capability may very well be elevated by means of smaller expansions.
“I might additionally like to see a restart of some sort of venture on the Keystone XL. Perhaps that route was not the fitting one,” she advised the viewers.
“I feel we now have to be life like. If we find yourself with a Republican within the White Home, I feel that we find yourself with a Keystone allow being signed into regulation the identical day. I feel that that’s how strongly the Republicans really feel about power safety.”
Commercial 4
Article content material
Nonetheless, in right now’s present setting, “it’s a moot level as a result of I don’t suppose there’s any personal sector firm within the present setting that will be prepared to take the danger,” the premier later advised reporters.
Trade specialists agree.
“The likelihood of that precise pipeline being revived is lower than one in 10, perhaps two in 10,” mentioned Chris Bloomer, former CEO of the Canadian Vitality Pipeline Affiliation.
“KXL, it was all about politics when it comes to the opposition . . . When you undergo the ache of taking that massive a write-down, the definition of madness is to maintain doing the identical factor time and again.”
In Calgary, let’s hope the percentages of a Inexperienced Line being constructed are larger, as town is experiencing huge inhabitants development and desires enhanced transit.
Final week, the province pulled its $1.5-billion funding dedication for the venture. The primary part just lately noticed its estimated price ticket escalate by $705 million to $6.3 billion, whereas decreasing its protection in south Calgary.
Like KXL, a number of political currents are at play, together with inner council division, and the UCP authorities blaming former Calgary mayor Naheed Nenshi for the venture’s woes. Nenshi, now the Alberta NDP chief, fired again that “the UCP authorities has chosen to make this a political concern.”
Commercial 5
Article content material
On Tuesday, council will talk about a advice by metropolis administration on how they might wind down the Inexperienced Line and switch it over to the province.
“There’s a lot politics across the Inexperienced Line, as there could be with any infrastructure venture,” mentioned Mount Royal College political scientist Duane Bratt.
“Then, you throw in a number of orders of presidency and that provides to the complexity. Then, you add the partisan make-up on the provincial stage.”
Requested this week concerning the Inexperienced Line, Smith famous the primary part will price extra, but not prolong as far south as was initially deliberate, working from the downtown to Lynnwood-Millican, as an alternative of extending to a Shepard station at a hundred and thirtieth Avenue S.E.
“The venture began off as a 46-kilometre route that will price $4.4 billion. Everybody was enthusiastic about it. And it’s the unbelievable shrinking venture,” the premier mentioned.
“Each time a brand new announcement got here out, it acquired smaller and smaller, and it didn’t meet its authentic dedication.”
The province will ask an engineering agency to supply it with an alternate route, however critics level out the venture has been extensively studied.
In the meantime, companies look ahead to readability amid the confusion and finger-pointing.
“The function of politics is to search out out what’s proper, not who’s proper,” Calgary Development Affiliation president Invoice Black mentioned Thursday.
“My hope is the politics relax, hopefully slightly little bit of knowledge prevails, and the necessity to get issues achieved — and to do it proper — will prevail.”
Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.
Article content material
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25621155/Screenshot_2024_09_14_at_3.30.48_PM.png?w=150&resize=150,150&ssl=1 "NASA’s Starliner astronauts don’t really feel ‘let down’ by Boeing’s spacecraft")
